About this blog

My name is Bill Hirt and I'm a candidate to be a Representative from the 48th district in the Washington State legislature. My candidacy stems from concern the legislature is not properly overseeing the WSDOT and Sound Transit East Link light rail program. I believe East Link will be a disaster for the entire eastside. ST will spend 5-6 billion on a transportation project that will increase, not decrease cross-lake congestion, violates federal environmental laws, devastates a beautiful part of residential Bellevue, creates havoc in Bellevue's central business district, and does absolutely nothing to alleviate congestion on 1-90 and 405. The only winners with East Link are the Associated Builders and Contractors of Western Washington and their labor unions.

This blog is an attempt to get more public awareness of these concerns. Many of the articles are from 3 years of failed efforts to persuade the Bellevue City Council, King County Council, east side legislators, media, and other organizations to stop this debacle. I have no illusions about being elected. My hope is voters from throughout the east side will read of my candidacy and visit this Web site. If they don't find them persuasive I know at least I tried.

Saturday, February 2, 2013

Bellevue City Council Still Doesn't Get It



The majority of the Bellevue City Council members apparently still don’t understand the concept of “permitting”.   I attempted to explain the issue to them at their November 13th “extended session” (See 11/10/13 post for my comments.)   The January 25th Bellevue Reporter article on the issue prompted me to send the below  “Letter” to the Bellevue Reporter Jan 26th rather than to try again with the BCC.  I hoped they might relax their “word limits” because of the permit issue’s importance to the area.  They declined to include it in this week’s BR so I decided to add it to this blog.  


Letters,
The January 25th Bellevue Reporter front page article “Second meeting set on amending code for light rail” is another example that the majority of the Bellevue City Council still doesn’t get it.   Their plans to “complete work on the overlay by the end of February” is an abdication of their responsibility to their constituents as well as the entire eastside.

There surely is no need to rush this issue since serious East Link construction is at least three years away.   Any agreement should be predicated on Sound Transit dropping the requirement for a maintenance facility in Bel-Red area and for Bellevue paying $200 million for a tunnel through city center.   ST recently agreed to tunnel from the University to Northgate without any such surcharge.  (The BCC still hasn’t explained how they intend to get the $200 million.)

Any East Link permitting agreement may be nullified by either of two legal actions aimed at stopping East Link.  The Freeman/ETA suit attempts to block Sound Transit from using the I-90 center roadway for light rail.  The Building a Better Bellevue lawsuit argues Sound Transit violated federal environmental law when it refused to consider a tunnel from South Bellevue through the city or bus rapid transit (BRT) for I-90 Bridge.  Both lawsuits have very good chances for success.  (See the 1/25/13, 12/12/12, 12/07/12 posts on blog http://stopeastlinknow.blogspot.com for details).

For far too long the BCC has kowtowed to Sound Transit demands and deadlines.   They need to refuse to accede to ST latest demands to relax permitting requirements for the East Link debacle.

Friday, February 1, 2013

BBB Suit Also Potential Winner



On January 25th the U.S Department of Transportation, Federal Transit Administration and others filed their final response to the Building a Better Bellevue’s suit action concerning alleged environmental violations.   Like the Freeman v WSDOT/ST (See 1/25/13 post), this seems like an easy case to win.

For example, the below paragraph from page 2 of 14:

As applied to this case, where the planning efforts of state and local transportation officials have come to focus on the problem of extending the light rail system to serve a particular corridor, it makes little sense in an environmental analysis to study the environmental impacts of the bus-based options which plaintiffs say federal defendants should have also evaluated.

In essence the defendants are saying there was no need to evaluate “bus options” if Sound Transits “focus” is on the problem of extending light rail”.   Even ST didn’t believe that since they spent 30 years evaluating various cross-lake configurations to select the “no build” options in the DEIS and FEIS  documents.

The fact ST never seriously considered the BRT (i.e. two-way, bus-only service on center roadway) “bus option” with its far greater capacity and accessibility at far less cost shows a lack of competence.  (See 12/7/12 post for details)  ST confiscation of the center roadway for light rail will increase cross-lake congestion not decrease it.  (See 8/08/12 Post)

The defendants’ response concerning the “tunnel alternative” was to admit ST didn’t consider that option.

The notion of tunneling was raised only during scoping and rejected at that nascent stage in the process. It was never pursued thereafter in any serious fashion by any party.

However, it’s significant that the “Tunnel Alternative” was the only Segment 5 configuration that didn’t violate federal environmental law by intruding on the Mercer Slough Park when it was rejected.  It wasn’t until August 2005 that the regulation was changed from precluding such actions unless there were “no feasible and prudent alternatives to the use of land” to "such actions result in a de minimis impact”.   Its not clear whether the court can disagree with the defendants apparent decision the Mercer Slough Park impairment or the devastation to the plaintiffs’ neighborhood is de minimis .

The defendants also make a major point of the failure of the plaintiffs to pursue the tunnel alternative earlier.  For example from Page 5 of 14;

At no time did plaintiffs, or any other party, comment that a tunnel alternative in Segment B was a feasible and reasonable alternative for the South Bellevue segment that should have been evaluated in the FEIS.  Therefore, plaintiffs’ objection to the adequacy of the FEIS on that ground has been waived.

However during the period the Defendants claim the plaintiffs should have argued for the “Tunnel Alternative” ST was demanding Bellevue pay an additional $200 million if they wanted a tunnel rather than a street level train route through the city center.   Any attempt to request a tunnel for the much longer route in Segment B would presumably result in ST demanding substantial additional funds. 

Therefore, the plaintiffs instead attempted to convince the Bellevue City Council and ST to use the B7 alternative.  This route would have eliminated their neighborhood concerns and substantially reduced Mercer Slough impairment.  It was only after these attempts had been rejected did they initiate their current action to protect their neighborhood, as well as Mercer Slough Park, with the “tunnel alternative” or BRT on the I-90 center roadway.   

The question for the court would seem to be “Did the delay in raising the “Tunnel Alternative” issue cause ST any material harm?”  The fact ST recently committed to tunnel the far longer distance from the University Station to Northgate without requiring any surcharge would seem to negate any claims they “suffered” from the delay or that the “tunnel alternative” resulted in substantial additional costs. (Or for any of the other reasons ST originally rejected this option in the East Link  “scoping”.)

Again, to this retired engineer this seems like an easy case to win.

Friday, January 25, 2013

Freeman/ETA Suit Should Stop East Link



The Oral Arguments for the Freeman v State of Washington are scheduled for 1:30 PM, February 19.  It should be any easy case to win if the below paragraphs copied from the WSDOT/Sound Transit Oct 2 "Brief" filing is their response to the suit in court.

In September 2004, the Federal Highway Administration' s Record
of Decision designated R-8A (the HOV Project) as the selected
alternative. CP 1406, 1419-69.  This alternative was chosen because it "would accommodate the ultimate configuration of I-90 (High Capacity Transit in the center lanes)." CP 1407, 1432.

C.       Analyzing the Installation of High Capacity Transit in the 1-90 Center Lanes
With federal project approval in 2004, the signatories to the 1976 Agreement, along with Sound Transit, took the first step toward installing High Capacity Transit in the center lanes of I-90.

In the 52004 Amendment to the 1976 Agreement, the parties agreed to the principle that upon completion of the HOY Project, they would "move as quickly as possible to construct High Capacity Transit in the center lanes." CP 1008, 1034. The parties defined "High Capacity Transit" as: a transit system operating in dedicated right-of-way such as light rail, monorail, or a substantially equivalent system. CP 1033.

The parties also committed to the "earliest possible conversion
of center roadway to two-way High Capacity Transit operation based on outcome of studies and funding approvals." CP 1407, 1472. • ~4).

The September 2004 Federal Highway Administration document,  “I-90 Two-Way Transit and HOV Operation Project, Record of Decision”, purported to justify the East Link use of center roadway does nothing of the sort.  It’s true the R8-A alternative" would accommodate the ultimate configuration of I-90 (High Capacity Transit in the center lanes)."  However, as the below paragraph from my 5/16/12 post explains, the R8-A from the 2004 study was not the R8-A configuration selected for East Link.  

The study’s preferred configuration, R-8A, is documented on pages 9 and 10.   It adds a 4th lane to the outer bridges for the combined bus/HOV traffic.  However, it provides the needed additional capacity by retaining the two existing reversible bus/HOV lanes on the center roadway.  Thus, contrary to what Sound Transit and DOT told the judge, there is not a shred of data that supports their claim that R-8A’s installation of a Bus/HOV lane on the outer bridge would eliminate the need to use the center section for highway use.

The other absurdity is the WSDOT/ST apparent unwillingness to consider bus rapid transit (BRT) as a “High Capacity Transit” for the center lanes.  BRT would provide far greater capacity and accessibility at far less cost than light rail.  The 1976 Agreement includes “upon completion of the HOY Project, they would move as quickly as possible to construct High Capacity Transit in the center lanes”.   I-90 BRT could have been initiated 15 years ago. 

The WSDOT/ST failure to ever seriously consider BRT for the I-90 Bridge center roadway, along with their delay in implementing the 4th lanes on the outer roadways, has been a historic blunder.  Their incompetence has resulted in hundreds of millions wasted and years of added congestion for cross-lake commuters. 

Hopefully this case will end this debacle before additional billions are spent on an East Link program that will devastate parts of Bellevue, inevitably gridlock 1-90 Bridge and do nothing to ease congestion along SR405 and I-90 corridors.

Tuesday, January 22, 2013

WSDOT I-90 Toll Proposal Not the Answer for SR520


Last week’s Bellevue Reporter (1/18) headline “State to talk I-90 tolls at Bellevue meeting” should be no surprise.   I-90 tolls however are not the way to ease I-90 congestion or to fund SR520 construction.  First of all revenue from forcing I-90 commuters to pay tolls for a bridge they’ll never use will still be far short of what’s required.  Second, Eastside residents already pay more than their “fair” share with the .9% sales tax that accounts for about 40% of all Sound Transit revenue. 

Unfortunately nearly all that money has been and will continue to be spent for several more years on Sound Transit’s Central Link.  Much of the money ST has spent on the eastside has been wasted promoting a flawed East Link light rail proposal.  


ST and the WSDOT need to recognize their decision to ignore bus rapid transit (BRT) for center roadway was a monumental blunder.  They’ve not only wasted millions, they’ve forced cross-lake commuters to needlessly endure years of increased congestion.  Allowing East Link to proceed will result in additional billions wasted on a light rail system that will devastate parts of Bellevue, inevitably result in gridlock on 1-90 Bridge, and do nothing to ease congestion along SR405 and I-90 corridors. (Unless BBB or Freeman/ETA suits stop East Link)

The East Link money, again much of which comes from the eastside, should be used to pay for the SR520 corridor construction and eliminate tolls on either bridge.  If ST and WSDOT fail to recognize the need for doing so the eastside legislators, rather than approving their request for adding 1-90 tolls, should use their oversight authority to insist on this action.  Doing so will benefit the entire eastside.  It’s way past time for them to stop kowtowing to ST and WSDOT demands and start representing their constituents.

Tuesday, January 15, 2013

Sound Transit Incompetence Continues


The January 11 Bellevue Reporter headlines “Sound Transit to start probing along light rail line’’ is another example of ST incompetence.  Any concerns they may have about installing light rail tracks along the route into Bellevue pale in comparison to those associated with light rail operation on the I-90 Bridge.

No one has ever attempted to install a train on a floating bridge.  The concern is with the ability of the “expansion joints” connecting the “floating” and “fixed” portions to withstand the loads from the train’s four 74-ton cars. (The original bridge joints have already needed replacement under less severe loads.)

The Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) was sufficiently concerned they responded to the Draft Environmental Impact Statement on February 23, 2009 (HRW-WA/WA624).  It concluded  “We do not agree that enough work has been done to justify that it is feasible to design an expansion joint to accommodate light rail”. (The “work” they referred to was some 2005 tests the WSDOT had conducted using “flat-bed” trucks.  See 7/04/12 post for more details)

Chapter 7 of the Final Environmental Impact Statement (FEIS) does mention these concerns: “The Federal Highway Administration’s (FHWA’s) concerns on the Draft EIS focused on the feasibility of light rail on the floating bridge and requested additional information on the feasibility of an expansion joint to accommodate light rail.“

Table 7-1, Common Comments, includes the following question and ST’s response

         CC3n   Can the I-90 floating bridge structure support the light rail?                                    

The Washington State Legislature Joint Transportation Committee commissioned an independent review team (IRT) to evaluate the bridge design with light rail. The IRT concluded that all issues identified as potentially affecting feasibility can be addressed.

It’s “interesting” that ST chose to refer to a study commissioned by the legislature rather than conduct further studies in the intervening 2 ½ years.  The fact the independent study concluded “all the issues identified can be addressed” surely suggests more needs to be done. 

As the 7/04 post points out future studies may conclude that structural concerns could limit each train to only 2 cars; halving East Link’s already meager capacity.  The fact ST still refuses to do those studies nearly 4 years after the FHWA raised concerns is just another example of their incompetence.

Sunday, January 6, 2013

Sound Transit and Seattle Times Still Don't Get It




The Seattle Times Friday (1/04) article “Slide parks Sounder Again” is another example of how neither they nor Sound Transit recognize the absurdity of ST’s Northline Sounder operation. 

Sound Transit spent more than $500 million creating the Northline Sounder operation, presumably under the dubious assumption that large number of riders would choose to ride a train to the King Street Station rather than an express bus route to central business district.

My 06/12 post “Sound Transit’s Other Debacle” explained in detail how the Northline Sounder failure to attract riders along with the high operating costs for the train has forced ST to subsidize each rider by up to $20,000 a year (doesn’t include depreciation or capitalization costs)

The Seattle Times chose to ignore the operating cost subsidy, depreciation costs and those associated with the initial $500 million.  Instead their 10/24 Editorial, “No Way to Run a Commuter Line” criticized ST for not meeting ridership expectations because “Sounder North had not met expectations” for reliability with comments “getting to work cannot be a roll of the dice”.   They implied Sound Transit should do “something” to prevent the mudslides that forced cancelling train service and “simplify things” to attract commuters who preferred destinations other than King Street Station.   

My 10/26 blog post pointed out the Times recommendation to prevent future blockages would be very expensive or they would have been done long ago.  The Times suggestion to “simplify things,” presumably meaning provide alternative Seattle destinations, was not practicable. 

The recent 1/04 article essentially debunks the entire Times 10/24 editorial.  Commuters within walking distance of the King Street Station, aren’t that concerned about the cancellations.  They know they always have the bus option in either direction with very similar commute times.  However, whenever possible they much prefer to spend an additional $1.00 in fare to ride in a partially empty train rather than a standing-room-only bus.


Unfortunately ST doesn’t accept the fact that not enough commuters use this option to make Northline financially viable.  Most public transit systems would reduce the number of expensive train trips and increase number of buses.  ST prefers to keep the buses crowded in a futile attempt to increase train ridership.  (Central Link ridership has benefitted from cancellations or “rerouting” of competing bus routes.)  It's what happens with a public transit system that only gets about 5% of its funds from fare box revenues.




Friday, December 28, 2012

Council and Board Member Obligations


The prior 5 posts dealt with the two pending lawsuits concerning stopping East Link: The BBB suit attempt to overturn the Records of Decision (ROD) issued by the U.S. Dept. of Trans. and the Federal Transit Administration (FTA); and the Freeman/ETA action appealing the Kittitas judge's ruling allowing Sound Transit to install light rail on I-90 Bridge.

Both present potentially very strong arguments. ST surely violated federal environmental law when their DEIS and FEIS documents failed to consider BRT, a feasible and prudent alternative that would have avoided the environmental damage along the route into Bellevue.  The Kittitas judge’s decision should be easy to reverse because ST and WSDOT lied when they claimed adding a 4th lane to the outer roadways would eliminate the need to use the center roadways for highway needs and could therefore be used for light rail. 

Unfortunately, judges may not agree with a retired engineer’s belief it’s a “slam dunk”.   I therefore sent the following email to Sound Transit Board members, King County Council, and the Bellevue City Council. 

Dear Sound Transit Board, Bellevue City Council, King County Council,
Your organizations would be well advised to give serious consideration to the information included in the 12/15, 12/12, and 12/07 posts on my blog http;//stopeastlinknow.blogspot.com.

Respectfully,
Bill Hirt (former candidate for 48th District No 1)

My intention was to contact those who might have been swayed by WSDOT East Link support and were unaware of East Link legal challenges.  I also hoped they might choose to read some of the earlier posts.  For example the 7/19 post concerning WSDOT culpability and the 11/14 post identifying the big East Link benefactors, the ABCWW and their unions.

None of the organizations' members chose to respond directly.  However, my blog has had a huge increase in number of page views.  Not only were they “viewing” the posts dealing with the legal arguments many have also read the 7/19 and 11/14 posts along with the original 05/15 post, “The Case Against East Link”.   

I’m assuming several of the “new” viewers were council or board members.   If ST does happen to prevail in the upcoming legal actions, responsible board or council members will hopefully speak out against the East Link debacle. 

Hundreds of millions have already been wasted on light rail.   The ST delay in adding the 4th lanes to the outer roadways for 15 years is most likely due to their concern that moving the HOV traffic would force them to consider BRT for the center roadway.  Allowing ST to continue another 3-4 years will waste additional millions and needlessly extend congestion. 

The wasted millions and needless congestion pale in comparison to the debacle if ST is allowed to proceed.   In 2016-17 they'll close down the center roadway and begin spending billions installing light rail on the bridge and devastating the area along the route into Bellevue.  Anyone who would knowingly allow that to happen is not fit for public office.  This blog is an attempt to make the board and council members aware of their obligation to the entire eastside.