About this blog

My name is Bill Hirt and I'm a candidate to be a Representative from the 48th district in the Washington State legislature. My candidacy stems from concern the legislature is not properly overseeing the WSDOT and Sound Transit East Link light rail program. I believe East Link will be a disaster for the entire eastside. ST will spend 5-6 billion on a transportation project that will increase, not decrease cross-lake congestion, violates federal environmental laws, devastates a beautiful part of residential Bellevue, creates havoc in Bellevue's central business district, and does absolutely nothing to alleviate congestion on 1-90 and 405. The only winners with East Link are the Associated Builders and Contractors of Western Washington and their labor unions.

This blog is an attempt to get more public awareness of these concerns. Many of the articles are from 3 years of failed efforts to persuade the Bellevue City Council, King County Council, east side legislators, media, and other organizations to stop this debacle. I have no illusions about being elected. My hope is voters from throughout the east side will read of my candidacy and visit this Web site. If they don't find them persuasive I know at least I tried.

Thursday, September 3, 2020

Seattle Times Response to ST “Transit Development Plan 2020-2025

 

The Seattle Times Sept 2 Editorial, “Speak Up on Sound Transit Plans” typifies the paper’s failure to acknowledge ST incompetence. The editorial opines::

 

“The comment period will provide an opportunity for a broad conversation about transit plans going forward, as Sound Transit decides which projects to delay and possibly shelve”.

 

The editorial concludes:

 

“Concerned residents should review and comment on what’s in the works’.   Consider it the start of a vital, regional discussion”.

 

The Times apparently believes that after more than a decade of failing to urge Sound Transit be audited, a 30 minute comment period regarding their Transit Development Plan 2020-2025 will end Sound Transit incompetence.  

 

The paper neglects to mention those wanting to comment will have to go to the Sound Transit Sign Up window at 8:00 a.m.  That they will be called in the order they signed up.  That the 30 minute comment period will severely limit either the time each commenter will have or the number of those able to comment.

 

The Times still doesn’t recognize Sound Transit’s real problem contending:

 

 “The promised spine linking Everett, Seattle, and Tacoma must be completed”.    

 

The rationale being:

 

 “The needs of outlying areas that paid heavily into the system with little investment in return”.  

 

The paper apparently doesn’t recognize the DSTT limited light rail capacity to where the riders added by the extensions beyond UW and Angel Lake will reduce access to current Link Light rail riders, potentially ending access during peak commute.  

 

The editorial suggests:

 

Substantial revisions to Sound Transit’s work plan, including the current mix of rail and buses, may be needed

 

Apparent “may be needed” regarding buses is the paper’s response to the TPD reducing ST Express annual Revenue Vehicle Miles from 16.5 million in 2019 to 8.2 million in 2025 and bus passenger trips from 17.5 million to 8.0 million.  If the Times really wanted to help “outlying areas” they would have urged Sound Transit add thousands of parking stalls with access to added ST express bus routes into Seattle. 

 

Sound Transit doesn’t even add parking with access at light rail stations.  Choosing instead to use Link Light Rail to replace current ST express bus routes into Seattle.  Ending the bus routes will reduce transit capacity into Seattle, do little to reduce I-5 congestion, and reduce access for current Link riders. 

 

The bottom line is the Seattle Times has spent the last decade abiding if not abetting Sound Transit incompetence.  For years the “Traffic Lab” has been the Seattle Times project that digs into the region’s thorny transportation issues.  The editorial attempt to make up for their failure by urging “concerned residents” to respond to a 30-minute TPD comment period is absurd.

 

Tuesday, September 1, 2020

Sound Transit CEO Rogoff Incompetence Continues


Sound Transit is required to prepare a six-year transit development plan and annual report, as well as conduct a public hearing about the proposed plan.  This year’s Transit Development Plan 2020-2025 and 2019 Annual Report was released on July 16th and is scheduled for public comment 12:00 p.m. -12:30 p.m. Sept 3rd.  

Typical of Sound Transit they limit the comment period to 30 minutes.  Even worse rather than allow those wishing to comment to sign up prior to the meeting they’ll be required to go to the Sound Transit sign up window beginning at 8 a.m. on the day of the hearing.  They will be called in the order they signed up.  The 30-minute comment period will severely limit either the time each commenter will have or the number of those able to comment. 

Anyone reading the TDP would understand why Sound Transit would want to limit comment. In particular, their decision to wait until page 24, Chapter “V: PLANED ACTIVITIES, 2020 – 2025” for their response to COVID-19.

Sound Transit is evaluating service levels and the timing of capital projects as a result of reduced revenues stemming from the COVID-19 pandemic and subsequent economic downturn.  The process began in May 2020 with an overview of potential financial impacts and will continue through summer of 2021.

The following information is accurate as of the adoption of the 2020 Budget and Transit Improvement Plan at the end of 2019 and do NOT reflect impacts of the COVID-19 Pandemic.

One would have thought the results from a “process that began in May 2020” could have been included in a July 16th TPD.  Instead they chose to call it a “Draft”.  Still the TPD illustrates CEO Rogoff’s incompetent approach to public the area’s transportation problem.

First, he’s apparently “unaware” I-976 passed with TPD projecting MVET revenue will continue, increasing from $346 M in 2019 to $407 M in 2025.  Even more important, the TPD projections for 2025 demonstrate Rogoff’s delusional approach to area’s congestion. 

He clearly doesn’t appreciate the benefits of increased bus transit capacity. The TPD reduces ST Express annual Revenue Vehicle Miles from 16.5 million in 2019 to 8.2 million in 2025, reducing bus passenger trips from 17.5 million to 8.0 million.  Rogoff does so while promising to implement BRT along I-405 and north of Lake Washington in 2024.

By comparison his TPD increases annual Link Light Rail Total Vehicle Miles from 5.7 million in 2019 to 24.0 million in 2025.  The increase reflects more frequent service, added cars per train, and additional route lengths with the extensions to Northgate and beyond to Lynnwood, across I-90 to Bellevue and beyond to Redmond, and beyond Angel Lake to Federal Way.

All of the Link Light Rail trains in 2025 will pass through the Downtown Seattle Transit Tunnel (DSTT).  An August 2004 PSRC Technical Report, funded by Sound Transit, “High Capacity Transit Corridor Assessment”, concluded DSTT station lengths limited Link Light Rail trains to 4 cars and safe operation required 4 minutes between trains.  Thus the PSRC study would limit Link Light Rail to 60 cars an hour in each direction.

It’s not clear what assumptions Rogoff was using for the TPD in 2025 since the billions spent on the extensions do nothing to increase the number of train cars through DSTT.  The PSRC concluded each 74-seat car could accommodate 148 riders so ridership was limited to 8880 riders per hour in each direction or 17,760 total.  Again, it’s not clear what Roffoff’s TPD assumed for number of cars per hour or riders per car.  The TPD projects Link Light Rail “Passenger Trips” will increase from 24.8 million in 2019 to 84.0 million in 2025, or 280,000 a daily.  Ridership would have to exceed 37,000 hourly during the 3-hour morning and afternoon commutes to accommodate 80% of the 280,000 daily riders.  


Clearly, at least during peak commute Link Light Rail doesn’t have the capacity. (Even 4 minutes between trains may be optimistic because of the difficulty of merging return trips from different East Link and Federal Way route lengths and stops.) Riders added by extensions will reduce access for current Link riders. All of the parking with access to light rail has been full for years yet the TPD Capital Improvement budget includes nothing for parking  Instead Rogoff intends to use extensions to replace existing bus routes.  The TPD “Planned Activities” includes “discontinuing service on ST Express” between Bellevue and Seattle in 2023, and between Lynnwood and Seattle and Federal Way and Seattle in 2024. 

Rogoff apparently doesn’t recognize congestion on I-5 and I-90 is not due to too many buses. He’s spending billions on light rail extensions that don’t increase transit capacity to eliminate bus capacity into Seattle.  During peak commute those former bus riders could end access for current Link Light Rail commuters.

It’s no wonder he wants to minimize TPD input.  He apparently has no idea how to deal with the COVID-19. It won't take until 2025 to see the his TPD problems.  The first indication will be failure of the billions spent on Northgate to reduce I-5 congestion when it begins operation.  East Link operation in 2023 will simply confirm the debacle.





Monday, August 17, 2020

What Does It Take to Open Schools?


The Sunday Seattle Times “Back to School” article goes into considerable detail about the pandemic’s effect on education.   The lesson from the spring closure was:

“U.S public school students learned less than half of the math and just under 70 percent of the language arts skills they would have learned if schools had remained open last spring”

The articles proposal “Avoiding a repeat of spring” details some attempts to improve education this fall with little assurance of success.  It identified the “decision-makers”, Gov. Inslee, Local health departments, and School Districts, but didn’t provide any information as to what was required before schools can be open for “in-person” learning. 

Health officials had earlier concluded they needed to keep schools closed in counties classified as “high risk” if they exceed 75 cases per 100,000 residents. That “high-risk” status is likely to continue for as long as they continue testing 15-20,000 daily. 

Heath officials are no longer willing to tell how many are even being tested so it’s unclear what percentage are testing positive. However, it’s “unlikely” the state will ever achieve the “Washington state goal 2% positive over 2 weeks” for those willing to go through the hassle of testing. 

Those making the decision should consider the Aug 15, 14 day average positives, 663, only resulted in forty 14-day average hospitalizations or 6%.   Those over 80 had 5% of the cases but 51% of the fatalities with 27% mortality.  Those 60-79 had 14% of cases and 38% of fatalities and 7% mortality.  Those 20-59 had 10% of cases and 0.43% mortality.  Those under 20 had 13% of cases with no fatalities.  The "real" mortality rates were significantly lower since many with the virus were asymptomatic or didn't get tested.  Also, some of those older who died, and the 11%, 20-59, fatalities presumably had other contributing factors.  

Keeping schools closed deprives the children in 29.7% of Washington households all the benefits of a classroom education and their parent’s ability to work.  Health officials need to provide realistic guidelines that balance the safety concerns against the benefits.  It should go beyond counties to informing individual school districts how many in their district tested positive to how many were hospitalized, what the ages were for those who died and if they had any contributing factors.  Again do it by district, not by county.

Inform the school district, parents, and teachers. Let districts decide to have in-person classes for parents and teachers for those who want it and remote for those who don't.  Unless they do schools could be closed for a long time. . 



Friday, August 14, 2020

Seattle Times Self-inflicted Wound


The Seattle Time Aug 13th edition continues their recent attempts to justify a Free Press Subsidy.  Action is needed because:

“This system is in peril of imminent collapse, which would exacerbate the current civil discord across the country and jeopardize democracy and freedom as we know them.”

It’s unclear why the Free Press Subsidy is needed to prevent an imminent collapse of the system.   One could reasonably argue it’s the media and the Times that have spent the last three years “exacerbating the current civil discord”.   Whatever actions took place prior to Trump’s election would have never been an issue if Hillary had won. 

Since Trump’s election the divisiveness has been the result of Times and most of the media acting like an active wing of the DNC, denying his legitimacy, denigrating his successes, and exaggerating any failures.

The article claims:

“Because of your support and the Blethen family’s five generations of unwavering commitment to public service, The Seattle Times has become a role model and a beacon of light for the survival of our nation’s local free press system.”

While the Times may be a “role model” they apparently haven’t attracted much support from the other 50 regional metro newspapers.  It’s also not clear “the other 84% controlled by absentee financial opportunists damage local communities and civic engagement and deepen social fault lines by disinvesting in the quality and volume of local journalism”.

The justify the need for support claiming

Today’s free press and economic crises are the result of a serious erosion of checks and balances at least three decades in the making. 

Only the Times would claim the current “economic crises” was “at least three decades in the making”.  Much of the Times problem is self inflicted. The Times “filtered” approach to local and national problems turns off much of the more conservative older generation.  Younger voters are more attracted to the Internet.  Losing readers devalues advertising.

The Times approach to “Capitalism” exemplifies the paper’s approach to national issues.  The article claims “Capitalism is the most productive economic system the world has ever seen”. Yet concludes:
 
“Our capitalistic economic system has been co-opted by Wall Street at the expense of Main Street and healthy local economies. Wealth has been dangerously concentrated and left many Americans with little hope of working hard and building a secure life and family.”

Prior to the pandemic, the country’s economy was an historic success with record low levels of unemployment, wage growth, and economic prosperity.  It’s not clear how the paper proposes to “Address the dysfunctional control of our capitalism and wealth by far too few individuals and avaricious corporations.

The paper is rightly concerned about the need  “to regulate the Internet for public good rather than allow Facebook and Google to evolve into secretive, monopolistic and dangerous fiefdoms”.   However the papers real concern is not with how Facebook and Google “filter” their information it’s because they “prevent local media from profiting and competing in the digital advertising space”.
The Times solution a “Free Press Super Fund, funded by a fee on the major internet platforms” would have more credibility if supported by other regional papers whether or not they were locally owned.  

Again the Times could add to the value of its advertising by attracting more readers.  Instead they’ve spent a decade alienating much of their audience with their response to both national and local problems.









Wednesday, July 29, 2020

The End of My Gubernatorial Campaign?


My candidacy for governor is likely to end next week.  It was never about winning but an attempt to use the campaign as a platform to tell the entire state residents deserve better.  (As expected the Seattle Times neglected to mention my candidacy despite finishing 3rd in 2016.)  It's another attempt to tell voters the Puget Sound area has already paid and will continue to pay a heavy price for Sound Transit and WSDOT failure to deal with area’s roadway congestion.

Voters were misled when they approved Sound Transit Prop 1 light rail extensions beyond UW, across I-90, or beyond SeaTac.  Funds spent on those extensions should have been spent increasing bus transit capacity along I-5 and I-90 corridors with added parking and express bus routes. Light rail funds should have been used to expedite light rail to Ballard and West Seattle.  The WSDOT should have been forced to limit HOT on I-405 to one HOV lane with fees raised to assure 45 mph throughout the commute leaving an additional lane for GP.

Sound Transit CEO Peter Rogoff may be able to construct light rail extensions.  However his ridership claims for the $96 billion light rail extension in the 2019 Budget Plan for 2017 to 2041 are delusional.  It’s only a question of whether Northgate operation in 2021 or East Link operation in 2023 demonstrate that debacle. 

The end of my candidacy will likely allow Rogoff to continue spending billions more on additional extensions.   The extensions will increase rather than decrease congestion and require additional billions to cover the shortfall between the longer route operating costs and fare-box revenue.

None of this would have been possible without the connivance of the Seattle Times, who abetted the incompetence, the city councils who approved the permits needed, and the legislators who enabled Sound Transit votes for funding.  They all likely welcome the end of my campaign.

The entire state has already paid and will pay even more if the end of my candidacy allows Gov Inslee and others to perpetrate the “Green New Deal”.    The claim “CO2 emissions are an existential threat” is based on the failure of climatologists computer model results to match measured temperatures.   They concluded matching computer results required anthropogenic (man--made) CO2 emissions have 30 times the effect on global temperatures as increasing energy from the Sun.  That sensitivity to CO2 is the basis for the need to slash fossil fuel emissions.

However the National Academy of Science in 2015 debunked that claim, concluding global warming is “likely caused” by addition solar radiation from the Sun.  A NASA 2019 paper concluded CO2 could increase from the current 410 parts per million “to 1000 to 2000 or to 5,000 and it won’t warm the earth”.

The end of my candidacy would also continue the futility of even attempting to significantly reduce fossil emissions.  A July 1 2020 U.S. Energy Information Administration, “Today in Energy” reported the hundreds of billions spent adding wind turbines over the last 40 years provided only 2.5% of the energy consumed in 2019.  Whatever funds spent adding solar panels over that period provided only 1.0% of the energy consumed in the U.S. in 2019.

The problem has been only 35% of windmill capacity and 25% of solar power capacity is actually consumed by customers.  Until large amounts of energy can be stored for when the wind doesn’t blow or the Sun doesn’t shine the trillions spent adding wind turbines and solar panels will require fossil fueled generators for backup.  Thus it's unlikely the Green New Deal plan will ever provide more than a fraction of the country's energy used by consumers.

Much of any new wind and solar power will be generated far from where it’s needed, adding to the costs. By comparison fossil fuels can be found, transported, and stored near where the energy is needed.

Sooner or later my Sound Transit concerns and the futility of attempting to limit fossil emissions will be validated. Ending my campaign will make it later.




Friday, July 24, 2020

The Futility of the “Green New Deal”



The previous post detailed why I looked forward to having the opportunity to using National Academy of Science and NASA to use “Science” to debunk Gov Inslee’s support for “Green New Deal”. This post details there’s two reasons why it's fortunate “science” debunks the claim, “CO2 emissions are an existential threat”. 

The first being the US only emits 15% of global CO2 emissions.  It’s unlikely U.S. “leadership” will persuade China, India, and “undeveloped other” countries to significantly reduce their 67% of emissions. Spending trillions attempting to reduce U.S. emissions will have minimal effect on global temperatures.  

The second being its “unlikely” the Green New Deal will significantly reduce U.S. dependence on fossil fuel.  A July 1 2020 U.S. Energy Information Administration, “Today in Energy” report announced “Non-fossil sources accounted for 20% of U.S. energy consumption in 2019”.  

However it also reported the hundreds of billions spent adding windmill capacity over the last 40 years provided only 2.5% of the energy consumed in 2019.  Whatever funds spent adding solar power capacity over that period provided only 1.0% of the energy consumed in the U.S. in 2019.

The problem is only 35% of windmill capacity and 25% of solar power capacity is consumed by customers. A wind turbine looses nearly 90% of its capacity if wind drops from 20 mph to 10 mph. Adding windmills in less "windy" conditions will undoubtedly reduce that capacity factor.  (The European windmill capacity factor is only 21%.)   Solar power drops with clouds and goes away at night. Until large amounts of energy can be stored wind and solar power will never be a reliable energy source requiring fossil fueled generators for back-up.   The fact that much of both wind and solar power is generated far from where it’s needed adds to the costs

By comparison fossil fuels can be found, transported, and stored near where the energy is needed, be it in a vehicle or airplane, a coal or natural gas power plant, heating a building, farming, or other industrial use (chemical, metallurgical, and mineral transformation).  (The energy stored in battery-powered cars “likely” comes from fossil powered plants)

My hope is to use the gubernatorial platform to tell the widest possible audience it’s unlikely the trillions spent on the Green New Deal will ever change that reality.


Friday, July 17, 2020

My Global Warming Denier Gubernatorial Platform


My Voters’ Pamphlet Statement this year reflects my attempt as a gubernatorial candidate to tell the widest possible audience Al Gore’s “Inconvenient Truth” about CO2 emissions is in fact a monumental lie.   My hope was to use the general election as a platform to debunk Gov Inslee, one of the most prominent advocates for "CO2 emissions are an existential threat”.   

The reality is the Seattle Times decision to promote “Republican leaders” choice fractures the anti-Tim Eyman vote and other candidates willingness to spend funds on totally futile attempts to defeat Inslee make it less likely I’ll be on the ballot this fall. 

It's unfortunate since none of the other campaign ads I’ve seen have dealt with Sound Transit and WSDOT failure to reduce congestion or Seattle Times abetting that failure.  Also no one has mentioned the futility of Inslee's attempts to reduce the state’s carbon emissions with windmills, solar panels, or battery powered cars as the way to reduce global warming.

My global warming denier platform debunking the CO2 emission concerns would rely on two sources. (Replacing earlier analysis in Voters' Pamphlet) The first would be a National Academy of Science Nov 10th 2015 paper:

Shortwave and Longwave Radiative Contributions to Global Warming Under Increasing CO2

The paper concluded:

Altogether, these results suggest that, although greenhouse gas forcing predominantly acts to reduce Outgoing Longwave Radiation (OLR), the resulting global warming is likely caused by enhanced Absorbed Solar Radiation (ASR)


The NAS clearly concluded global warming was the result of increased warming from the Sun not from increased radiation from the atmosphere due to CO2.

The second was a NASA Dec 9th 2019 paper “Solar Cycle 25 Prediction 2019 – Bing”.  It included charts concluding the following:

Global Warming Ruse - Temperatures Getting Colder. CO2 is not a player

CO2 warning is a myth. The real threat is cold beginning of a new little ice age epoch in 2020.

It’s going to the cold for a very long time

CO2 warming effect decreases with concentration. CO2 has less and less effect with increased concentration.   CO2 can go to 1,000 to 2000 or to 5,000 and it won’t warm the earth. 

I look forward to the opportunity of using NAS and NASA to support my "global warming denier"  platform this fall.