About this blog

My name is Bill Hirt and I'm a candidate to be a Representative from the 48th district in the Washington State legislature. My candidacy stems from concern the legislature is not properly overseeing the WSDOT and Sound Transit East Link light rail program. I believe East Link will be a disaster for the entire eastside. ST will spend 5-6 billion on a transportation project that will increase, not decrease cross-lake congestion, violates federal environmental laws, devastates a beautiful part of residential Bellevue, creates havoc in Bellevue's central business district, and does absolutely nothing to alleviate congestion on 1-90 and 405. The only winners with East Link are the Associated Builders and Contractors of Western Washington and their labor unions.

This blog is an attempt to get more public awareness of these concerns. Many of the articles are from 3 years of failed efforts to persuade the Bellevue City Council, King County Council, east side legislators, media, and other organizations to stop this debacle. I have no illusions about being elected. My hope is voters from throughout the east side will read of my candidacy and visit this Web site. If they don't find them persuasive I know at least I tried.

Sunday, July 12, 2020

Seattle Times “Republican” Gubernatorial Candidate


The Sunday Seattle Times article “GOP Pack Aims at Inslee” typifies the paper's and some "Republican's" arrogance when it comes to who they think the party should support.  It says a lot they would choose to describe Raul Garcia, who is “pro-choice”, hasn’t bothered to vote since 2012, and is “undecided” as to whether “he will vote for Trump” as “someone Republican leaders back for governor”.

The reality is Inslee is going to be re-elected.  The only question remains is who best can use the candidacy as a platform to benefit Washington residents.  The Times refuses to even acknowledge my candidacy despite the fact I finished 3rd in 2016 having never asked for nor accepted any financial support for my campaign.  They (and some "Republicans") obviously don't want a candidate who will point out the paper's incompetent response to the area's problems, with the paper instead becoming an active wing of DNC.   

My general election platform would expose the  failure of Sound Transit and the WSDOT to deal with the area’s congestion.  That Sound Transit CEO Rogoff may be able to construct light rail extensions but he's totally incompetent when it comes to increasing the transit ridership needed to reduce congestion.  His 2019 budget plans to spend $96 billion on a light rail spine that will increase congestion and create a perpetual financial "black hole" to cover operating cost.   

Puget Sound residents need to be told how they would benefit if Sound Transit were required to divert light rail spine funds to increase bus transit capacity and light rail lines to West Seattle and Ballard. East side residents would benefit if WSDOT limited HOT to one I-405 lane with fees raised to assure 45 mph and an additional lane for GP.

The entire state needs an election platform debunking the claim “CO2 emissions are an existential threat”. Global temperatures are driven by the Sun.  Taxes on carbon or windmills and solar panels will do absolutely nothing to stop it.    

The bottom line is, unless other candidates support these issues, East Link operation in 2023 will vindicate my Sound Transit concerns; I-405 congestion will continue to increase on both GP and HOT lanes; and renewable energy and carbon taxes will continue to increase resident’s costs.  

Sooner or later all of my concerns will be validated.  My campaign is an attempt to make it sooner.




Thursday, July 9, 2020

Puget Sound Residents Deserve Better


My candidacy for governor is not about winning but to use it as a platform to tell the entire state residents deserve better.  The Puget Sound area has already paid and will continue to pay a heavy price for Sound Transit and WSDOT failure to deal with area’s roadway congestion.

Voters should have never approved Sound Transit Prop 1 light rail extensions beyond UW, across I-90, or beyond SeaTac.  Light rail routed through the Downtown Seattle Transit Tunnel (DSTT) doesn’t have the capacity to justify the cost of construction and operation of their light rail spine.

The legislature should have never enabled Sound Transit to ask voters for any ST3 funds, let alone the $64 billion in taxes they anticipate getting as a result by 2041.  Sound Transit CEO Rogoff’s 2019 Budget Plan for 2017-2041 should have been a “wake-up” call for anyone who believed Sound Transit’s ST3 funded light rail extensions will reduce I-90 or I-5 congestion.  

While Rogoff may be able to construct a “light rail spine”, his ridership claims in the 2019 budget for the $96-billion expansions were delusional.  He demonstrated even more incompetence with a 2020 "budget" that failed to include any details as to how the money will be spent operating the transit modes for the year.  The Sound Transit Board response was to renew his contract for three years with a hefty raise.

His decision to use light rail to replace bus routes with light rail exacerbates the capacity problem.  It reflects his failure to recognize I-5 and I-90 congestion is not due to too many buses.  Ending current routes will reduce transit capacity into Seattle and increase roadway congestion.  Any riders added by the extensions will also reduce access for current Central Link riders. 

East side commuters have paid and will continue to pay an especially heavy price.  Sound Transit should have never been allowed to confiscate the I-90 Bridge center roadway for East Link.  That doing so precluded two-way BRT, with 10 times light rail capacity, 10 years sooner, at I/10th the cost.

Mercer Island residents deserve better from a city council that could have stopped East Link by disallowing permits Sound Transit needed.  They compounded that problem by failing to take legal action to prevent Sound Transit from using the island as a terminus for I-90 corridor buses.  Even worse their agreement with Sound Transit will halve I-90 corridor transit routes, increasing congestion along the entire corridor.

The Bellevue city council made a similar blunder by also approving East Link permits.  The result has been the end of Bellevue’s persona as the “city in the park”.  They allowed Sound Transit to make a mockery of environmental laws, ending the quiet solitude of the Mercer Slough Park and devastating a beautiful tree-lined boulevard into downtown Bellevue. 

The council also allowed Sound Transit to scar Bellevue skyline with their version of a viaduct with 4-car trains trundling through BelRed on elevated tracks for 18 hours a day.  They allowed Sound Transit to create a huge maintenance facility in the Spring District resulting in noisy light rail trains doing so during the early morning hours of the day.

All of this could have been prevented.  Again, Mercer Island and Bellevue could have disallowed East Link permits.  Their would have been no East Link if the WSDOT hadn't "misled" a federal judge in the Freeman litigation claiming the center roadway wasn’t needed for vehicles. The ignored a   2004 FHA ROD refuting that claim.  A.G. Ferguson allowed Sound Transit to violate the environmental laws and ignore RCW 81.104 requirements they consider lower cost bus transit options. 

Residents deserve better from a Seattle Times that  played a major role in abetting Sound Transit incompetence.  The Times never included auditing Sound Transit in their list of top 10 priorities for legislators.  Even a cursory review would have exposed the problems. Instead they advocated for tolls to reduce congestion, refusing to recognize that, without an alternative route, tolls only raise the cost.

In the end, East Link operation in 2023 will demonstrate it increases I-90 corridor congestion and reduces transit capacity into Seattle from SeaTac.  That large numbers of commuters will be “dissuaded” from using transit because of the hassle of transferring to and from light rail on Mercer Island and accessing light rail at one of the two stations in the DSTT. 

The lack of increased capacity and ridership with the longer routes will necessitate the entire area pay a huge subsidy to cover the operating cost-fare/box revenue shortfall. In short, East Link will quickly be regarded as the biggest boondoggle in transportation history.

East side commuters also deserve better than a  WSDOT that neglected to limit HOT to one lane on I-405.  The 2 HOT lanes have increased congestion on the remaining GP lanes to where more drivers are willing to pay the fees than the two HOV lanes can accommodate to meet 45 mph target. Again, 2 HOT lanes on I-40 increased GP lane congestion and failed to meet 45 mph for those willing to pay the fees.  Future growth will exacerbate both problems.

The WSDOT could have raised the fee on one HOV lane to limit traffic to the 2000 vph required to assure 45 mph for the entire commute.  (The assured velocity would make far more I-405 BRT routes attractive than Sound Transit plans for 6 routes an hour.) The added GP lane would have reduced congestion for those unwilling or unable to pay.  One can only hope the delay in adding lane between Bellevue and Renton reflects that recognition.

The bottom line is my gubernatorial candidacy provides a platform to detail why Puget Sound Residents deserve better.  They deserved a Seattle a Seattle Times that would have exposed the failure of Prop 1 and ST3 to address area's congestion.  They deserve a Sound Transit CEO who recognizes light rail limitations in our area.  That the only way to reduce congestion on I-5 and I-90 is to dramatically increase bus transit ridership with added parking and bus routes into Seattle and Bellevue.

East side residents deserve better than what they've gotten from their city councils and what they'll get from ST3.  They certainly deserve more than what they'll get from WSDOT plans for 2 HOT lanes on I-405.  Seattle residents deserve to have their ST3 funds spent on light rail extensions to Ballard and West Seattle, not a light rail spine that reduces their access.  

Again I look forward to making my case this fall on this and why the entire state deserves better. 


t

Monday, June 29, 2020

IPCC and “Expert Reviewers” Ignores National Academy of Science


An April 7, 2020 release was the latestinformation available on Internet concerning the IPCC AR6 status.  It included the following excerpts:

The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) has extended government and expert review of the second order draft of the Working Group I contribution to the Sixth Assessment Report (AR6) by six weeks to allow reviewers more time in the light of disruption caused by the COVID-19 pandemic. 

The review, which opened on 2 March 2020 and was originally scheduled to end on 26 April, will now close on 5 June. Interested experts can register until midnight CET on 29 May at https://apps.ipcc.ch/comments/ar6wg1/sod/register.php

The Working Group I contribution to the AR6, Climate Change 2021: The Physical Science Basis, will assess large-scale climate changes, climate processes and feedback and regional climate information. The Working Group I report includes an interactive online atlas, which is also open for review comments.

The draft report has been prepared by 233 authors from 65 countries.
The first order draft of the Working Group I report received 23,462 comments from 750 expert reviewers. So far, 2,277 experts have registered to review the second order draft.

However the only “experts” with access to AR6 Working Group 1 (WG1) first or second order drafts are those who “register” with IPCC.  Presumably the 750 who reviewed the first order draft and those who finally “registered” to review second order draft continued concurring with IPCC AR5 conclusions:

Human Influence on the climate system is clear.  Increasing anthropogenic emissions have thirty times the impact of increasing radiation from the Sun on global temperatures.

One wonders how many “experts” they chose were from the National Academy of Science (NAS).  Wikipedia NAS description includes the following:

Founded in 1863 as a result of an Act of Congress that was approved by Abraham Lincoln, the NAS is charged with "providing independent, objective advice to the nation on matters related to science and technology. … to provide scientific advice to the government 'whenever called upon' by any government department."

The NAS published the following paper online on Nov 10, 2014.  (More than a year after the AR5 Climate Change September 2013 Physical Science Basis Working Group Report)AR5 ClimateScience Bas

Shortwave and Longwave Radiative Contributions to Global Warming Under Increasing CO2

The paper’s Abstract began with:

In response to increasing concentrations of atmospheric CO2, high-end general circulation models (GCMs) simulate an accumulation of energy at the top of the atmosphere not through a reduction in outgoing longwave radiation (OLR)—as one might expect from greenhouse gas forcing—but through an enhancement of net absorbed solar radiation (ASR).

It concluded with :

Altogether, these results suggest that, although greenhouse gas forcing predominantly acts to reduce OLR, the resulting global warming is likely caused by enhanced ASR.


The bottom line is nearly 6 years ago NAS concluded global warming was driven, not by increased blockage by anthropogenic CO2 (fossil fuel emissions), but by increased absorbed radiation from the Sun.

It’s “unlikely” the IPCC AR6 WG1 first or second order drafts reflect the NAS conclusion.  It says a lot about the status of climate debate that, nearly 6 years later, 233 authors, 750 “expert reviewers” of first draft, and more than 2770 “expert reviewers” of second draft were either unaware of the NAS conclusion or chose to ignore it.

My campaign for governor is an attempt to expose their failure.



Sunday, June 21, 2020

Bellevue Incompetence Continues


The recent Bellevue Transportation Dept “Access to Bellevue 2020” Keeping Bellevue moving forward,” exemplifies an approach to transportation that prompted my “activism” more than 10 years ago.  Anyone with a modicum of public transit competence would have recognized Sound Transit’s 2008 East Link “Draft Environmental Impact Statement (DEIS) was sheer fantasy.

Light rail routed through the Downtown Seattle Transit Tunnel (DSTT) didn’t have the capacity needed to accommodate both I-90 and south Seattle public transit needs.  Sound Transit should have never been allowed to confiscate I-90 Bridge center roadway precluding 2-way BRT with ten times the capacity, 10 years sooner, at a 10th the cost.   There was never any justification to devastate the route into Bellevue, permanently scarring the city skyline with elevated light rail tracks.

The Bellevue city council decision to ignore attempts to explain why they should not approve the permits Sound Transit needed prompted me to file as a candidate in 2012 to attract viewers to this post detailing those problems.   Eight candidacies, 600 posts, and more than 150,000 views have failed to prevent Bellevue from abetting Sound Transit’s East Link; what will surely be regarded as one of the biggest transportations boondoggles in history.

The problem is not Sound Transit’s ability to construct an East Link light rail extension and light rail stations through Bellevue to the Bel-Red area.   The problem is, with the exception of the 1500 parking stalls in South Bellevue Park and Ride, the extensions and stations limit access to residents who live within walking distance of light rail stations.  A fraction of what's needed to justify operating costs and reduce area's congestion and 

In July 2019, the BTD proposed adding access to the East Main station via “transit oriented development to take advantage of the new transportation system”.  It included a plan to use the land use code to force the Red Lion Hotel, Hilton Hotel, the Bellevue Club, Radiant Logistics, Citadel Church, and Savers to relocate to allow residential development including “affordable housing”. 

The East Main “Transit Oriented Development” was apparently replaced 2020 with BelRed Transit Oriented Development near the Operation and Maintenance Facility, and Spring District/120th and BelRed/130th light rail stations.  The 2020 BelRed Transformation depicts huge developments around both stations.  Again promising they’ll provide affordable housing in the “mix of retail and public space and market rate housing”. 

However the current status is the BTD is “Requesting Proposals” for 120th station and “In Planning” for 130th Station.  One would think the BTD, after having more than 10 years of BelRed planning, current status would be more than “requests for proposals” and ‘In planning” to base access for riders.  Potential residents and businesses “may” not be attracted to noisy 4-car trains trundling past on elevated tracks for 18 hours a day.

Even Sound Transit recognized the need to increase access.  In 2014 they proclaimed 40,000 of their projected 50,000 daily riders would be those forced to transfer from buses to light rail for the cross-lake commute.  Their recent “bus intercept” agreement with Mercer Island to terminate bus routes on island requires Sound Transit and King County Metro halving I-90 corridor routes to provide access to light rail on island.

The bottom line is the BTD 2020 plan for “Keeping Bellevue moving forward” will do nothing for the 68% of Bellevue residents who consider congestion their major concern.  That when the Covid-19 pandemic does pass the downtown Bellevue will again anticipate 18,000 more will be added to the 52,000 who will likely return.  Most of the 50,000 originally planned for Microsoft’s expanded Redmond Campus will likely return to work.    

East Link operation in 2023 will demonstrate only a tiny fraction of both will commute via light rail.  It’s the others the BTD should now be making plans to help with their commute. 


Thursday, June 11, 2020

NAS Debunks IPCC Climate Change Concerns


Previous posts have detailed a retired Boeing engineer’s response to the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) claim “Human influence on the climate system is clear”.  The posts originally reflected IPCC apparent refusal to recognize global warming between 1910 and 1950, before any significant fossil emissions, was essentially the same as from 1970 to 2000 during which fossil emissions quadrupled earlier emissions.

Posts were also dubious of IPCC using computer models to claim fossil emissions must have initially 10, but later 30 times the impact of the Sun on global temperatures in order for the results to match measured temperatures.  

The posts opined IPCC ignored Ice core data from 800,000 years of temperatures and atmospheric CO2 levels for four prior Interglacial periods. Global temperatures during the Eemian Interglacial Period some 126,000 years ago were 4 deg C higher with CO2 levels 290 parts per million (ppm).  It’s “possible” the increasing temperature during the period warming was the result of some “feed back” from increasing CO2.  However the only rational reason for the subsequent drop in temperatures was a drop in energy from the Sun.  Thus it’s “likely” both warming and cooling and CO2 increasing and decreasing were driven by the Sun. 

The warming from 290 ppm CO2 reflected its ability to block radiation back to space.   A global energy flow chart for 2000 to 2004 showed  ~370 ppm atmospheric CO2  “back radiation” was ~94% of surface radiation.  (Back radiation increased to 96% for 410 ppm)    It’s “unlikely” the IPCC claim an increase in back radiation from additional fossil emissions to the current 96% level is “an existential threat”.

Again those posts attempting to debunk IPCC claims were the result of a retired skeptical Boeing engineer’s observations of readily available data.  Thus I was pleased to find “scientific support” from a National Academy of Science report published on line Nov 10, 2014.

Shortwave and Longwave Radiative Contributions to Global Warming Under Increasing CO2

It included the following “Significance” and “Abstract”.   (The italics on the conclusions are mine.)

Significance
The greenhouse effect is well-established. Increased concentrations of greenhouse gases, such as CO2, reduce the amount of outgoing longwave radiation (OLR) to space; thus, energy accumulates in the climate system, and the planet warms. However, climate models forced with CO2 reveal that global energy accumulation is, instead, primarily caused by an increase in absorbed solar radiation (ASR). This study resolves this apparent paradox. The solution is in the climate feedbacks that increase ASR with warming—the moistening of the atmosphere and the reduction of snow and sea ice cover. Observations and model simulations suggest that even though global warming is set into motion by greenhouse gases that reduce OLR, it is ultimately sustained by the climate feedbacks that enhance ASR.

Abstract
In response to increasing concentrations of atmospheric CO2, high-end general circulation models (GCMs) simulate an accumulation of energy at the top of the atmosphere not through a reduction in outgoing longwave radiation (OLR)—as one might expect from greenhouse gas forcing—but through an enhancement of net absorbed solar radiation (ASR). A simple linear radiative feedback framework is used to explain this counterintuitive behavior. It is found that the timescale over which OLR returns to its initial value after a CO2 perturbation depends sensitively on the magnitude of shortwave (SW) feedbacks. If SW feedbacks are sufficiently positive, OLR recovers within merely several decades, and any subsequent global energy accumulation is because of enhanced ASR only. In the GCM mean, this OLR recovery timescale is only 20 y because of robust SW water vapor and surface albedo feedbacks. However, a large spread in the net SW feedback across models (because of clouds) produces a range of OLR responses; in those few models with a weak SW feedback, OLR takes centuries to recover, and energy accumulation is dominated by reduced OLR. Observational constraints of radiative feedbacks—from satellite radiation and surface temperature data—suggest an OLR recovery timescale of decades or less, consistent with the majority of GCMs. Altogether, these results suggest that, although greenhouse gas forcing predominantly acts to reduce OLR, the resulting global warming is likely caused by enhanced ASR.

The National Academy of Science would surely also conclude “absorbed solar radiation” would be “enhanced” by more solar energy from the Sun.   The only concern about current global temperatures increasing is increasing solar energy from the Sun.  The IPCC claim fossil emissions have 30 times the impact of the Sun is absurd.  

There was never any need to spend hundreds of billions each year on windmills, solar panels, or battery powered cars.  The devastation from past attempts to limit fossil emissions will be dwarfed by that from the  Green New Deal.

All because the IPCC continues to ignore real science.


Abstract
In response to increasing concentrations of atmospheric CO2, high-end general circulation models (GCMs) simulate an accumulation of energy at the top of the atmosphere not through a reduction in outgoing longwave radiation (OLR)—as one might expect from greenhouse gas forcing—but through an enhancement of net absorbed solar radiation (ASR). A simple linear radiative feedback framework is used to explain this counterintuitive behavior. It is found that the timescale over which OLR returns to its initial value after a CO2 perturbation depends sensitively on the magnitude of shortwave (SW) feedbacks. If SW feedbacks are sufficiently positive, OLR recovers within merely several decades, and any subsequent global energy accumulation is because of enhanced ASR only. In the GCM mean, this OLR recovery timescale is only 20 y because of robust SW water vapor and surface albedo feedbacks. However, a large spread in the net SW feedback across models (because of clouds) produces a range of OLR responses; in those few models with a weak SW feedback, OLR takes centuries to recover, and energy accumulation is dominated by reduced OLR. Observational constraints of radiative feedbacks—from satellite radiation and surface temperature data—suggest an OLR recovery timescale of decades or less, consistent with the majority of GCMs. Altogether, these results suggest that, although greenhouse gas forcing predominantly acts to reduce OLR, the resulting global warming is likely caused by enhanced ASR.


The National Academy of Science would surely also conclude “absorbed solar radiation” would be “enhanced” by more solar energy from the 

Monday, June 8, 2020

Revisiting the Fossil Emission Hoax


The previous post detailed how the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) is proceeding with plans to release its 6th Assessment Report (6th AR) in 2022.   That when it’s released it will undoubtedly reassert the claim, “Human influence on the climate system is clear”.

The basis for “human influence” claim on temperatures is an August 2007, Scientific American article, “The Physical Science behind Climate Change”.  It concluded the anthropogenic CO2 emissions in their computer models had to have 10 times the effect of the Sun to match measured data.  The IPCC AR5 concluded new computer models required those emissions to have 30 times the Sun’s affect to match measured data.

The IPCC decision to minimize Sun’s impact on temperatures ignored 800,000 years of ice core data.    The four prior Interglacial periods show CO2 level was the result of increased out gassing from ocean when temperatures were warming and increased dissolution when temperatures were cooling.  Both warming and cooling and CO2 increasing and decreasing were driven by the Sun. 

The clearest example was the Sun warmed global temperatures during the Eemian Interglacial Period some 126,000 years ago to 4 deg C higher than current levels.  Yet CO2 levels never exceeded 290 parts per million (ppm) CO2 in atmosphere.   However while the Sun was responsible for increasing CO2 in atmosphere it was the CO2 in atmosphere that further warmed planet by blocking radiation back to space.    

The warming from 0 deg F without CO2 to 60 deg F shows most of the radiation to space was blocked with 290 ppm CO2   While it’s not clear what percentage was blocked, a global energy flow chart for 2000 to 2004 showed  ~370 ppm atmospheric CO2  “back radiation” (reflected) 333 out of 356 Watt/sq meter or ~94% of surface radiation. 

Recent data showed back radiation increased to 96% of surface emission, presumably the result of atmospheric CO2 increasing to 410 ppm.   The hundreds of billions spent annually on windmills, solar panels, and battery-powered cars during the 20 years have still resulted in blockage increasing by 2%.   However the “most likely” reason for recent global warming is not the 2% increase in blockage but an increase in Sun’s energy resulting in more energy to block.  The IPCC claim fossil emissions have 30 times the affect of the Sun is absurd.

It’s also “unlikely” allowing fossil emissions to increase back radiation above 96% would be “an existential threat”.   Al Gore’s “Inconvenient Truth” is in fact a monumental lie.  Spending trillions on the Green New Deal perpetrating that lie goes beyond absurdity to insanity.

Friday, June 5, 2020

Mercer Island Should Sue Sound Transit’


The May 27th MI Weekly article informed Mercer Island residents about their council’s objections to Sound Transit’s 60% design plans for the roundabout they intend to use to terminate I-90 buses on island.  The basic problem being:

Last October, we reiterated our concerns to Sound Transit over pedestrian safety, bus layovers, and a proposal to use the north curb frontage of North Mercer Way to drop off bus riders bound for light rail. 

The council was rightly concerned about  Sound Transit and King County Metro buses dropping riders off on the north side of North Mercer Way, forcing a bus load of riders to cross it every 2 minutes to get access to light rail. (Again assuming they both agree to halve current I-90 corridor bus routes they promised as part of the “bus intercept” program.) 


Sound Transit responded to the October letter with one in April repeating their unwillingness to accept the limitations imposed by the Settlement Agreement on their Bus/Rail Interchange.  However the Settlement Agreement Mercer Island agreed to included the following:

WHEREAS, Sound Transit is a regional transit authority created pursuant to chapters 81.104 and 81.112 RCW, with all powers necessary to implement a high-capacity transit system within its boundaries in King, Pierce, and Snohomish Counties;

Clearly Mercer Island granted Sound Transit “all powers,” so it’s hard to use the Settlement Agreement to object to where they “drop off riders”.  The Settlement Agreement was a major council blunder.  They attempt to counter the agreement with the following: 

Now is the time for all Islanders to engage in this final stage of light rail planning to ensure the best outcome for the Mercer Island community. Sound Transit needs to hear from our community. The City Council strongly encourages all interested residents to view and comment on these 60% design plans.

What’s really absurd is there would be no bus roundabouts on Mercer Island if the council had paid any attention to the hundreds of Mercer Island residents objecting to Sound Transit “bus intercept” plan.  Thus it’s hard to believe islanders response to roundabout plans will have any impact on Sound Transit.

The Mercer Island council could not only force Sound Transit to adhere to their roundabout concerns they could end their entire “bus intercept” plan.  The reason being Sound Transit’s planning for East Link violated RCW 81.104.100.  It details the code requirement for high capacity transit system planning with the following:

 (2) High capacity transportation system planning is the detailed evaluation of a range of high capacity transportation system options, including: Do nothing, low capital, and ranges of higher capital facilities.  High capacity transportation system planning shall proceed as follows:

 (b) Development of options. Options to be studied shall be developed to ensure an appropriate range of technologies and service policies can be evaluated. A do-nothing option and a low capital option that maximizes the current system shall be developed. 

Sound Transit clearly violated the RCW by never considering the low cost option of implementing two-way BRT on I-90 Bridge center roadway.  It could have had 10 times East Link capacity, at 1/10th the cost, 10 years sooner.  There would have been no East Link If Sound Transit had complied with RCW.  They surely can't use the RCW to claim they have “all power”.

The bottom line is the Mercer Island city council made a monumental blunder with their Settlement Agreement granting Sound Transit “all power”.   Islanders will pay for the council allowing Sound Transit to use the agreement to use island station to terminate I-90 bus routes.  The entire east side will pay because Sound Transit and King County Metro have agreed to halve current routes in order to do so.  

Again Mercer Island should sue not only to block Sound Transit roundabouts they should sue to stop “bus intercept”.  Islanders deserve it and the entire eastside would benefit.