About this blog

My name is Bill Hirt and I'm a candidate to be a Representative from the 48th district in the Washington State legislature. My candidacy stems from concern the legislature is not properly overseeing the WSDOT and Sound Transit East Link light rail program. I believe East Link will be a disaster for the entire eastside. ST will spend 5-6 billion on a transportation project that will increase, not decrease cross-lake congestion, violates federal environmental laws, devastates a beautiful part of residential Bellevue, creates havoc in Bellevue's central business district, and does absolutely nothing to alleviate congestion on 1-90 and 405. The only winners with East Link are the Associated Builders and Contractors of Western Washington and their labor unions.

This blog is an attempt to get more public awareness of these concerns. Many of the articles are from 3 years of failed efforts to persuade the Bellevue City Council, King County Council, east side legislators, media, and other organizations to stop this debacle. I have no illusions about being elected. My hope is voters from throughout the east side will read of my candidacy and visit this Web site. If they don't find them persuasive I know at least I tried.

Thursday, November 14, 2019

Next Year it’s for Governor


Again the votes are in and to no one's surprise I lost.   My candidacy attracted more than 11,000 votes despite the fact I had no desire to win and had not spent a dime campaigning. The Bellevue Reporter ignored my candidacy and the votes I received.   The Seattle Times opined one had to be a nihilist to vote for a perennial losing candidate opposed to Sound Transit.

During the campaign this blog also attracted more than 15,000 page views, “spreading the word about the Sound Transit debacle”.  I’m already looking forward to “spreading the word” beyond the King County 6th district by filing for governor in 2020. 

The “word” for Seattle is their 70% approval for ST3 funding is enabling Sound Transit to spend billions on light rail extensions attracting riders that will reduce their access to light rail.  Seattle’s ST3 taxes should be spent expediting a Ballard-to-West Seattle light rail link that will reduce congestion rather than a light rail spine that won’t.

The “word” for King County is about Sound Transit CEO Rogoff’s delusions regarding light rail benefits and his failure to recognize the benefits of BRT.   It's also about the stupidity of the WSDOT plan for 2 HOT lanes on I-405 between Lynnwood and Renton.  They should limit HOT to one lane with fees raised to assure 45 mph and use the 2nd lane for GP vehicles/

The “word” for Pierce and Snohomish counties is CEO Rogoff’s ridership claims for their light rail commuters are delusional.  That Sound Transit’s light rail spine won’t reduce congestion for their commutes into and out of Seattle and Bellevue.  Both would be better off if they dropped out of Sound Transit.

The “word” for the entire state is the futility of attempting to reduce the state’s CO2 emissions when the IPCC agreement allows China, which already exceeds U.S. emissions, to increase emissions until 2030.  I look forward to “challenging” Governor Inslee on the ability of higher gas and energy prices in Washington to combat “climate change”.

Sooner or later the entire area will recognize the Downtown Seattle Transit Tunnel (DSTT) will limit Sound Transit’s light rail spine to a fraction of the capacity needed to reduce I-5 and I-90 congestion.  That using light rail to replace bus routes will only hasten the lack of access for current Central Link riders in the city.  That, even with light rail's limited capacity, any commuter attempting to use light rail for the return route during peak commute will face utter chaos in the two DSTT stations.

That 100 additional BRT routes an hour into the city could add the equivalent of 5 lanes of capacity to I-5 and I-90 benefitting all three counties. And more could be added. The bus routes could be facilitated with +3HOV on both roadways during peak commute and an elongated T/C on 4th Ave for egress and access in Seattle.  The only limitation is the need to provide access with added P&Rs or local bus routes from near where commuters live to existing T/Cs. 

Again I intend to use my candidacy for governor to attract viewers to this blog.  Sooner or later everyone will recognize the inability of Sound Transit’s light rail spine and WSDOT’s 2 HOT lanes on I-405 to reduce congestion and the futility of reducing our state’s CO2 emission to alleviate climate change.  

The Seattle Times and the state’s legislators have spent a decade ignoring the need for an audit that would have exposed Sound Transit incompetence.   Until they do it’s just another year of billions wasted, more congestion, and increased cost for gas and energy.   My candidacy for governor is another attempt to stop it.

Saturday, November 9, 2019

A.G. Ferguson Will Again Block Lower Car Tab Fees


The news in the Seattle Times Nov 8th article about Seattle and King County seeking an injunction against I-976 is no surprise.   What should really alarm those who supported the initiative is the news the person defending it is State Attorney General Ferguson. 

A.G. Ferguson has been one of the most prominent enablers for all of Sound Transit Prop 1 light rail extensions.  For example there would be no East Link if Fergusons attorneys hadn’t “misled” a federal judge in the Freeman light rail lawsuit objecting to Sound Transit confiscation of I-90 Bridge center roadway. 

Ferguson’s lawyers claimed the center roadway could be used for light rail because their addition of a 4th lane (Alternative R-8A) on the outer roadway would make the center roadway unneeded for vehicles.  They supported that claim by referring to several studies, one of which was documented in  "I-90 Two-Way Transit and HOY Operations FEIS [(Final Environmental Impact Statement)] and ROD [(Record of Decision)]”.   Yet the ROD concluded the center roadway was still needed for vehicles with the added lane on outer roadways.

Ferguson’s lawyers allowed Sound Transit to make a mockery of Federal Transportation environmental laws regarding the need to protect the Mercer Slough Natural Park.  Sound Transit told the FHA and FTA that light rail “would not impact noise levels in the park”.  Yet Sound Transit agreed with Bellevue city council to spend millions shielding properties hundreds of feet away and across a major roadway.

Ferguson’s office allowed Sound Transit to ignore RCW 81.104.100 regarding the need to consider “no build” or low cost options (such as increased BRT) for any HCT.  Sound Transit’s response to that failure was to claim

Your presumption that this was due to the requirement in RCW 81.104.100(2)(b) is not correct. As indicated above, this statutory requirement applies to system-wide plans, not project level reviews.

Ferguson’s office response when asked whether it concurred with Sound Transit not complying included the following:

Our office does not advise or represent regional transit authorities, nor does our office have the role of supervising or correcting the activities of such authorities.

Clearly A.G. Ferguson’s office has shown a willingness to allow Sound Transit to do whatever it chooses.  Sound Transit’s mendacity regarding what the tabs would cost, the impact of the loss on light rail extensions, or the legal justification for using the value of one’s car to determine how much they pay for light rail will have no import.  Far more important, those who funded the I-976 opposition “may” be likely to contribute to his future campaign for Attorney General or Governor. 

Thus Ferguson’s claim defending I-976 is a “responsibility my office takes very seriously” is “likely” going to end up the same as his “defense of the Eyman initiative in 2016”.  Sound Transit will  be allowed to proceed, unabated, implementing Prop 1 light rail extensions that will inevitably be regarding as one of the biggest boondoggles in history.


Thursday, November 7, 2019

Seattle and King County Should Sue Sound Transit




The Nov 7th Seattle Times front page article, “Seattle, King county to sue over I-976” exemplifies their continued failure to recognize Sound Transit mendacity regarding Prop 1 and beyond” ST3 light rail extensions. Neither apparently recognizes Sound Transit “misled” voters with their 7/08/16 post claiming “An adult owning the median value motor vehicle would pay an additional $43 per year in MVET if ST3 were passed.”  

Yet they chose to respond to objections to the higher taxes in an April 2017 post headlined “Sound Transit 3 car tab rollback threatens light rail to Everett” claiming, “During the campaign, Sound Transit was completely transparent about the taxes.”   A Joel Connelly June 8th, 2017 Seattle PI article concluded that mendacity enabled ST3 since it would get “only 37% support were voters given a do-over”.   

Prior to the I-976 vote Sound Transit also “misled” voters claiming it would require an addition 20 years to complete the ST3 extensions. That the $6.5 billion car tab loss would also add $20 billion to the $96 billion Sound Transit CEO Rogoff’s 2019 budget for ST3 extensions.   I-976 would have “likely” had even more support without Sound Transit mendacity concerning its impact. 

If Seattle and King County want to take legal action to benefit not only commuters but all residents they should sue Sound Transit for its blatant mendacity regarding the benefits of the Prop 1 and beyond ST3.  Sound Transit’s decision to route the Prop 1 light rail extensions through the Downtown Seattle Transit Tunnel limited light rail capacity to a fraction of what’s needed to reduce congestion. 

Sound Transit’s plans to use the extensions to Lynnwood and beyond, to Federal Way and beyond, and to Bellevue and beyond to replace buses will do absolutely nothing to increase transit capacity into the city.  Any riders added by the extensions will reduce access for current riders.  The only thing the extensions do is increase the number of expensive train cars required and the costs of operating the trains over the longer routes.

The bottom line is not only would Seattle and King County have problems defending Sound Transit mendacity they would “likely” have difficulty convincing the court that the amount residents have to pay to fund light rail extensions should be based on the value of their car.


Instead Seattle should sue to force Sound Transit expedite the Ballard to West Seattle link and King County should sue to insist they divert light rail extension funds to more buses into and out of Seattle and Bellevue.  They could easily do so even with the loss of the car tab revenue.

Sound Transit’s failure to comply with RCW 81.104.100 regarding high capacity transit planning should make it a relatively easy case to win.  

And the whole area would benefit.

Thursday, October 31, 2019

Sound Transit's "Air of Haughtiness"


(I submitted the following to the Bellevue Reporter and am posting it since they may not use it and to reach those who don’t have access if they do.)

Sound Transit’s “Air of Haughtiness”
The Bellevue Reporter’s Oct 25th recognition I-976 “is not about rebar spikes and rail stations, it’s about an air of haughtiness of Sound Transit decision-makers” is surely justified.  However, Sound Transit’s “air of haughtiness” goes way beyond MVET taxes. 

Their 2019 budget plan will require Seattle Transit service area residents pay $64 billion in taxes between 2017 and 2041 for “Prop 1 and beyond” light rail extensions, primarily to replace buses with light rail trains. Sound Transit simply refuses to recognize that congestion on the area’s roadways is not due to too many buses. 

Sound Transit’s “air of haughtiness” is exemplified by their “bus intercept” plan agreement with Mercer Island. It halves current I-90 corridor bus routes and terminates them at the island light rail station.  Commuters from even that reduced number of buses will inundate the station and limit island commuter access to East Link.  Those able to ride buses will be forced to endure the hassle of transferring to and from East Link for commutes into and out of Seattle.  Those unable to do so will add to congestion I-90 corridor commuters already face.    

Even worse, east side commuters and residents will both have to pay hundreds if not thousands each year in ST3 taxes for Sound Transit Central Link extensions to Lynnwood and beyond, and to Federal Way and beyond.  This despite the fact they’ll rarely use them and that replacing buses with trains only increases transit operating costs and nothing to reduce congestion. 

However, Sound Transit’s “air of haughtiness” went too far with their response to RCW81.104.100 requiring they consider “no-build” HCT alternatives.  They claim East Link didn’t need to comply and they never considered adding Prop 1 bus routes along I-5 as a “no-build” alternative.  East side residents should use those failures to initiate a class action suit forcing Sound Transit stop the East Link “bus intercept” and use their ST3 funds to add bus routes rather than fund light rail extensions

As the editorial concludes, “I-976 is not about fixing roads, repairing bridges and saving lives, it’s about Sound Transit, its past, present and future”.  The east side future should include ending Sound Transit “bus intercept” and more funds for buses.

Saturday, October 26, 2019

Bellevue Should Send Sound Transit Message


Thursday’s flyer urging support for the current Bellevue City Council members reminded me of why I became an “activist” more than ten years ago.  I recognized Sound Transit’s 2008 East Link DEIS claims for benefits for light rail extensions across the I-90 Bridge center roadway were sheer fantasy. 

My efforts to stop East Link began with frequent council appearances urging they use the permitting process to require Sound Transit consider other I-90 Bridge transit options.  Even a cursory analysis would have concluded Sound Transit could've expedited their plans for 4th lanes on the bridge outer roadways for non-transit HOV and use the center roadway for two-way BRT.  That doing so would have provided 10 times East Link capacity, 10 years sooner, at 1/10th the cost. 

The council refused to do so, choosing to abide Sound Transit delaying for years the added 4th lanes that would have benefitted commuters from both sides of the lake.  They abided Sound Transit making a mockery out of FHWA environmental laws with claims light rail noise would have no impact on Mercer Slough Nature Park.  Yet they required Sound Transit spend millions shielding properties hundreds of feet away and across a major roadway.

They allowed Sound Transit to ignore an MOU committing them to finding alternative parking when they closed South Bellevue P&R, ending parking for access to transit for many. They justified allowing Sound Transit proceed with their Operation Maintenance Facility in Bel-Red with the absurd claim it would attract “1.1 million square feet of housing, office, and retail space" of "Transit Oriented Development".   They plan to spend millions transforming the East Main business district into a residential area to provide riders for Sound Transit’s light rail station there.
The bottom line is the Bellevue council has played a major role in Sound Transit confiscating the I-90 Bridge center roadway and devastating the route into the city for a light rail extension that will inevitably be considered as one of the biggest boondoggles in transportation history.  It’s time they finally did something to mitigate that debacle.
They can begin by joining other east side cities and take action to prevent Sound Transit from implementing their bus intercept plan.  Mercer Island residents will benefit from not having their island station used as a terminus for I-90 corridor buses.  Transit commuters will avoid the hassle of transferring to and from East Link for their morning and afternoon commutes. And all I-90 commuters will avoid the increased congestion when I-90 bus routes are halved when East Link begins operation.

However, even more important, all east side residents would benefit if the council took legal action to end Sound Transit using their ST3 taxes to fund their light rail spine.  They could do so for the same reason Mercer Island and other east side cities could sue to stop bus intercept.  

Sound Transit violated high capacity transit (HCT) planning requirements in RCW 81,104.100 (b).  They never considered adding BRT as the No Build Alternative for Central Link extensions to Lynnwood and beyond and to Federal Way and beyond. 

The Revised Code of Washington RCW 81.104.100 details the code requirement for high capacity transit system planning.  RCW 81.104.00 (2) and section (b) are shown below.

(2) High capacity transportation system planning is the detailed evaluation of a range of high capacity transportation system options, including: Do nothing, low capital, and ranges of higher capital facilities.  High capacity transportation system planning shall proceed as follows:

(b) Development of options. Options to be studied shall be developed to ensure an appropriate range of technologies and service policies can be evaluated. A do-nothing option and a low capital option that maximizes the current system shall be developed. 

When I raised this issue regarding East Link South Transit’s response was:

Sound Transit is in receipt of a complaint you filed with the Attorney General’s office asserting that Sound Transit failed to comply with RCW 81.104.100 in the development of options for the 1-90 Project.

As you noted in your complaint, Chapter 81.104 RCW requires development of a high capacity transportation system plan, and RCW 81.104.100 specifically sets forth the requirements that must be included in that system-wide plan. Sound Transit developed draft and final system plans that complied with these requirements and included extensive public outreach from 2005 to 2008. Draft and final supplemental environmental impact statements (EISs) on the updated system-wide plan were prepared in 2004 and 2005 respectively. The decision to implement East Link light rail was made as part of Sound Transit 2 (ST2), the system plan that was adopted by the Sound Transit Board and authorized by voters in Sound Transit’s taxing district in 2008.

Project level reviews are not subject to the requirements in RCW 81.104.100. As noted in your complaint, the project level review of the East Link project did include a no-build option. Your presumption that this was due to the requirement in RCW81.104.100(2)(b) is not correct. As indicated above, this statutory requirement applies to system-wide plans, not project level reviews. In addition, the project did evaluate conversion of the center roadway to two-way bus and operation, among other alternatives. The project to build chosen by the Sound Transit Board for the project includes lanes on the outer roadways of and the work to add those lanes will be completed this year.  


Sound Transit’s claim East Link was not required to comply with RCW 81.104.100 would seem to be grounds for legal action.  Especially since Sound Transits justified their “bus intercept” on compliance with RCW81.104 and 81,112. 

Even more important, the Sound Transit claim “Sound Transit developed draft and final system plans that complied with these requirements” would also seem “legally defective” regarding light rail spine RCW compliance.  

There is no indication Sound Transit ever considered adding more bus routes along I-5.  A 70-ft articulated bus can accommodate 119 sitting and standing riders.  Clearly any study would have concluded an additional 100 such buses an hour could have added more transit capacity than light rail at a fraction of the cost. 

The Bellevue council could use Sound Transit’s failure to comply with the RCW to take legal action to prevent east side taxes being used to fund a light rail spine they will rarely if ever use. Send Sound Transit a message that, unlike the Seattle Times, the Bellevue City Council  no longer condones the stupidity of spending billions to replace buses with light rail. Use the money to add the 100 bus routes an hour on I-90 and local bus routes from near where commuters live to provide riders. 

Candidates should justify voter support by promising to do so.










Wednesday, October 23, 2019

Seattle Times Car-Tab Malfeasance Continues


The Times Oct 22nd editorial “Addressing The Confusion I-976 Created” continuing their slavish support for Sound Transit qualifies as journalistic malfeasance: “wrong doing or misconduct”.   Again they chose to disparage the messenger rather than the message.   

It’s journalistic “misconduct” to suggest Tim Eyman’s legal problems justify I-976 rejection.  The Times claims, “The dishonesty is Eymans” yet gives no examples.  It was Sound Transit who “misled” voters with their 7/08/16 post claiming “An adult owning the median value motor vehicle would pay an additional $43 per year in MVET if ST3 were passed.”  

Yet the Times abided Sound Transit’s response to objections to the higher taxes in an April 2017 post headlined “Sound Transit 3 car tab rollback threatens light rail to Everett” claiming, “During the campaign, Sound Transit was completely transparent about the taxes.”

The message is a Joel Connelly June 8th, 2017 Seattle PI article concluded that mendacity enabled ST3 since it would get “only 37% support were voters given a do-over”.   Yet the Times continues to abide Sound Transit mendacity.  That Sound Transit claims the $6.5 billion loss out of their projected $64 billion in tax revenue. per 2019 budget, will add 20 years to light rail completion.

The Times claims this proposal will also “eviscerate transportation solutions chosen by gridlocked communities across our state” such as “sidewalk repairs”.  Yet the Times laments the fact “voters hundreds of miles from Puget Sound can weigh in.  Apparently concerned “communities across our state” aren’t that supportive.

Even the Times admits the car tab taxes are based on inflated car values.   That the “lawmakers should have reformulated the tax to better reflect car values”.   Yet the Times neglected to include that legislation as one of their top ten priorities.   

The bottom line is any “confusion” about car tab taxes is more the result of Sound Transit mendacity and the Seattle Times continued support.  That surely qualifies as journalistic malfeasance.  


Sunday, October 20, 2019

Seattle Times Still Doesn’t Get It


The Oct 19th Seattle Times editorial denigrating my candidacy is just the latest example they still don’t “get it”.  Even I was surprised that no one more “credible” had filed, ending my candidacy in the primary.  However I never expected such vitriolic responses to my being on the general election ballot. (I hope I'm not the only one who had to look up "nihilist")

The paper still doesn’t recognize (get it) that my candidacies have never been about winning but to use any candidate forums and the Voters’ Pamphlet to attract attention to this blog.  I recognized a long time ago that a single city or county council member or legislator wouldn't be able to deter Sound Transit plans for light rail extensions.   Those candidacies and my candidacies for King County Council Executive and Governor were attempts to reach larger audiences with my concerns rather than a rational chance for success. 

Even more important, the Seattle Times still doesn’t “get it” that Sound Transit is far more interested in constructing light rail extensions than in providing the increased public transit capacity needed to reduce congestion.  The Times Oct 11th article “Upstarts face well-heeled incumbents in races for King County Council” exemplified my concerns the transit agency’s light rail extensions will be “one of the biggest transportation boondoggles in history”.  That light rail operation will be a “disaster for the entire Eastside”.  That Sound Transit should have never been allowed to confiscate the I-90 Bridge center roadway and devastate the route into Bellevue.

The Times Oct 19th editorial chose to denigrate the messenger rather than debunk the message.  But then the editorial board has spent the last decade ignoring my message.  My first candidate interview in 2012 ended abruptly when I persisted with my view  48th district voters should be more concerned about Sound Transit’s plans for East Link than with the McCleary school funding issue. 

Since then I’ve referred the Times to more than 500 posts on this blog.  It has attracted more than 140,000 views to posts detailing problems not only with Sound Transit’s East Link but with all the Prop 1 extensions.  Several of the posts have detailed the paper’s Traffic Lab failure to “dig into the region’s thorny transportation issues”. 

For years the editorial board has ignored emails referring them to posts urging they include the need for the legislature to audit Sound Transit in their list of top ten priorities.  Even a cursory review would have shown Sound Transit’s decision to route the Prop 1 extensions through the Downtown Settle Transit Tunnel (DSTT) limited its capacity to a fraction of what was needed to reduce congestion.  That the billions spent on extensions will do nothing to increase transit capacity into Seattle. 

An audit would have also concluded any riders added by the billions spent on extensions would reduce access for current riders during peak commute.  That Sound Transit plans to use the extensions to replace bus routes will do little to reduce HOV lane congestion and nothing for GP commuters. 

Meanwhile Claudia Balducci, who may be a fine council member in many respects, also, still doesn’t “get it” regarding public transit.  For years Bellevue residents have considered congestion as a major concern with 67% doing so in the latest survey.  Yet East Link is never going to be the “fixed route, high capacity transit system” Balducci claims will reduce it.  Again, that possibility ended ten years ago when Sound Transit decided to route all the Prop 1 extensions through the (DSTT).  Even worse it precluded increased I-90 Bridge center roadway BRT that could.

As a Bellevue City Council member and later as mayor she ignored my many appearances urging they disallow the permits Sound Transit needed for East Link.  She ignored the results of a 2004 PSRC study, funded by Sound Transit, concluding the DSTT limited Central Link capacity to 8880 riders per hour in each direction.   East Link’s share of that capacity would never be sufficient to justify confiscating I-90 Bridge center roadway or devastating the route into Bellevue. 

She also ignored a 2004 FHA Record of Decision conclusion Sound Transit plans to add 4th lanes to the I-90 Bridge outer roadways would not make up for the loss of two lanes on center roadway.   Increased I-90 corridor travel times since center bridge closure reaffirm FHA concerns.  

Even more important, Balducci and the council ignored the opportunity to demand Sound Transit add the 4th lanes to the I-90 Bridge center roadway ten years ago for non-transit HOV.   Commuters from both sides of the lake would've benefited from both the added outer lane and the option of two-way BRT on bridge center roadway with 10 times light rail capacity at a fraction of the cost.

Instead Balducci’s steadfast East Link support “presumably” played a major role in her appointment to the Seattle Transit Board.  Anyone with a modicum of public transit competence would have recognized Sound Transit CEO Peter Rogoff’s 2019 budget plan to spend $96 billion between 2017 and 2041 was delusional.  That Rogoff didn't recognize the DSTT limits on light rail capacity or the benefits of added bus transit.  Yet she and the board chose to extend his contract for another 3 years with a substantial raise.

The bottom line it’s too late to do anything about Balducci’s prominent role in the East Link debacle.  However, it’s only the beginning of her 6th District residents being forced to pay for CEO Rogoff plan to spend most of the ST3 $96 billion on a light rail spine that will do nothing to reduce congestion and few  district residents will ever use. 

They and residents throughout the Sound Transit service area deserve better.  My candidacy is an attempt to attract the support needed to demand an audit exposing Sound Transit failure.  Sooner of later the entire area is going to recognize that failure.  Its time the Seattle Times “got it”, paid more attention to the message than the messenger, and demand the legislature expedite that recognition with an audit.


(I’m already looking forward to the Seattle Times response when I file as a candidate for governor in opposition to his attempts to reduce the state’s CO2 emissions.)