About this blog

My name is Bill Hirt and I'm a candidate to be a Representative from the 48th district in the Washington State legislature. My candidacy stems from concern the legislature is not properly overseeing the WSDOT and Sound Transit East Link light rail program. I believe East Link will be a disaster for the entire eastside. ST will spend 5-6 billion on a transportation project that will increase, not decrease cross-lake congestion, violates federal environmental laws, devastates a beautiful part of residential Bellevue, creates havoc in Bellevue's central business district, and does absolutely nothing to alleviate congestion on 1-90 and 405. The only winners with East Link are the Associated Builders and Contractors of Western Washington and their labor unions.

This blog is an attempt to get more public awareness of these concerns. Many of the articles are from 3 years of failed efforts to persuade the Bellevue City Council, King County Council, east side legislators, media, and other organizations to stop this debacle. I have no illusions about being elected. My hope is voters from throughout the east side will read of my candidacy and visit this Web site. If they don't find them persuasive I know at least I tried.

Thursday, October 17, 2019

6th District Commuters Deserve Better on I-405 and SR 520


The previous post detailed why East Link will be a disaster for east side I-90 commuters.  6th District commuters also deserve better from both Sound Transit and WSDOT on I-405 and SR 520.   Sound Transit waits until 2024 to implement their version of BRT on I-405 and to begin planning across SR 520.    It includes spending $300 million on a T/C near Kirkland with no parking for access.  Sound Transit plans for bus-only lanes on NE 85th St to provide access have been rejected by Kirkland. 

Sound Transit plan for BRT service consists, at most, of one bus every 10 minutes, making 10 stops for a 57-minute commute from Lynnwood to Burien.  (It’s not clear why they even call it BRT.) Typical of Sound Transit CEO Rogoff, their BRT ridership numbers are delusional.  If 80% of his projected 15,000 to 18,000 riders did so during the 3-hour morning and afternoon peak commutes, each of the 36 buses would have to carry between 333 and 400 riders.  Clearly more BRT service is needed.

6th District commuters deserve that additional BRT service to include direct routes from Woodinville, Brickyard, Totem Lake and Kirkland to Bellevue, Overlake and across SR520 to Seattle. Currently Woodinville commuters have to transfer to ST535 to get to Bellevue and none of the 3 have I-405 connections to Overlake or across SR520 to Seattle.

Meanwhile Kirkland commuters, who do have access to SR520 bus routes to Seattle, have no access to I-405 bus routes to Bellevue or Overlake.  Sound Transit waits until 2041 for light rail connections from Kirkland to Bellevue T/C and beyond to Issaquah.   

6th District commuters in all four cities deserve better.  Sound Transit should divert the $300 million from the 85th T/C to adding bus routes from all four along I-405 to Bellevue and to Overlake, and across SR 520 to Seattle.  Those working in all three locations should be surveyed as to where they live and when they would like to commute to and from work. 

That information could be used to add parking or route local buses to existing parking.    During peak commute each of the four should have BRT routes to Bellevue or Overlake, and across SR520 to Seattle every 10-15 minutes depending upon the demand. 

Those riding the buses should also be assured of reliable commute times.  Even Sound Transit BRT included the following proviso:

·  Relies on WSDOT to maintain adequate speed and reliability of I-405 express toll lane system

They recognized problems with I-405 HOV travel times with the WSDOT 2 HOT lanes between Bothell and Bellevue.  The benefit of HOT is predicated on raising fees on an HOV lane to limit the number of vehicles to what’s required to achieve the desired velocity.  The WSDOT target for 45 mph typically requires raising fees to limit traffic to 2000 vehicles per hour.

However, implementing HOT on 2 of 5 lanes has increased congestion on GP lanes during peak commute to where more than 4000 drivers were willing to pay the fees, reducing HOV lane velocities for both bus and +3 carpoolers.  Sound Transit is rightly concerned about the adverse affect on even its limited BRT service, especially with future growth.

Again, all 6th District I-405 commuters deserve better.  The WSDOT should be “allowed” to raise HOT fees on one HOV lane to limit traffic to the 2000 vph and revert the 2nd lane to GP.  The increased fees would assure 45 mph commute for those riding buses or willing to pay the higher fees.  The added GP lane would reduce congestion and travel times for those unwilling or unable to pay the fees.

6th District I-405/SR520 commuters deserve the option of either increased BRT with reliable commute times or less congestion for their own commute.

Sunday, October 13, 2019

Tip of the Iceberg


The recent article in the Seattle Times concerning my candidacy was a welcome surprise.  However, its comments about my opposition to East Link are only the “Tip of the Iceberg” when it comes to why I’m a candidate, (for the 8th time.) 

The article fails to detail why East Link will be regarded as “one of the “biggest boondoggles in transportation history”. That anyone with a modicum of competence would have recognized East Link’s share of light rail routed through the Downtown Seattle Transit Tunnel (DSTT) wouldn’t have the capacity needed to reduce I-90 bridge congestion.

That Sound Transit’s 2008 East Link DEIS was “mendacious” with claims it was the equivalent of up to ten lanes of freeway. They were “incompetent” when they failed to consider two-way BRT on I-90 Bridge center roadway as the “no-build” alternative.

That doing so violated the Revised Code of Washington RCW 81.104.100 requiring high capacity transit planning consider, “a do nothing option and a low capital option that maximizes the current system”.  Even a cursory review would have shown 2-way BRT on I-90 Bridge center roadway could have provided 10 times light rail capacity at a fraction of the cost

That the WSDOT was malfeasant when it allowed Sound Transit to confiscate the center roadway for East Link.  They should have recognized East Link didn’t have the transit capacity needed to reduce congestion.  They also ignored a 2004 FHA conclusion adding 4th lanes to the I-90 Bridge center roadway would not make up for the loss of the two center roadway lanes. The fact it currently often takes more than 40 minutes during peak commute for the 15.5-mile commute from Issaquah to Seattle confirms the FHA assessment.

Even worse, when East Link begins operation, Sound Transit’s “bus intercept” agreement to use light rail to replace I-90 Bridge buses will transform East Link from being "merely" a boondoggle to “a disaster for the entire Eastside”.   Again, Sound Transit’s confiscation of the I-90 Bridge center roadway has already increased outer roadway congestion. 

East Link was sold as a way to reduce that congestion, with DEIS promises “to increase person moving capacity across Lake Washington on I-90 by up to 60 percent”.  However, rather than adding transit commuters Sound Transit’s "bus intercept" uses East Link to replace I-90 bus routes.  Not only does ending cross-lake bus routes limit transit capacity to half the DSTT capacity, a far cry from the promised 60% increase, removing buses does little to reduce congestion on I-90 Bridge HOV lane and nothing on GP lanes.

Worse, the "bus intercept" plan has resulted in Sound Transit and King County Metro agreeing to half the current number of I-90 corridor buses.  Thus East Link operation will halve current transit capacity along the entire I-90 corridor. Thousands of vehicles will be added to the already heavy congestion along the entire I-90 corridor.

Those able to use remaining buses will be faced with the hassle of transferring to and from light rail on Mercer Island every morning and afternoon, a disincentive to even use transit.  Addition transit commuters will be dissuaded by the likely chaos in the two DSTT stations with thousands of commuters attempting to find access for their return trips.  Both will add to I-90 congestion and the East Link disaster.

That’s why the Seattle Times article, while welcome, was only the “tip of the iceberg" regarding billions spent on East Link.

Wednesday, October 9, 2019

Another year of Traffic Lab Failure


It’s been a year since Sound Transit CEO Peter Rogoff’s October 2018 presentation of his 2019 Budget Plan for 2017 to 2041 to the Sound Transit Board.   It should have been a “wake-up” call for those who believed Sound Transit’s ST3 “Prop 1 and beyond” light rail extensions would reduce congestion on the area’s roadways.  That Sound Transit CEO Rogoff plan to use $64 billion in taxes to implement what he proudly called “the most ambitious transit system expansion in the country” would do nothing to increase transit capacity into Seattle. 

The Traffic Lab could have told readers that $96 Billion will be spent over the next 22 years continuing King County Executive Dow Constantine’s Sound Transit Board decade of refusing to recognize the limitations of light rail and the effectiveness of BRT. That what Rogoff calls their new mission statement,  “We are connecting more people to more places,” was instead sheer fantasy.

Instead it’s been another year of their abiding if not abetting Sound Transit malfeasance.  Even the Seattle Times in a 4/03/16 editorial, “Questions on Transit Need Clear Answers” raised concerns. They questioned Sound Transit Chairman Dow Constantine’s “veracity”, the “wisdom” of committing to spend $50 billion over the next 25 years on light rail extensions. The editorial concluded:

The point is voters need their representatives to provide clear, objective explanations of ST3’s pros and cons, not cheerleading.  Costs and benefits of rail versus buses is one of several topics that must be clarified.

Even a cursory analysis would have recognized the benefits of high capacity transit buses.  A 70-ft articulated bus can accommodate 119 sitting and standing riders.  An additional 100 HCT buses an hour could provide rides for more than 10,000 commuters each hour, the equivalent of 5 lanes of 45 mph traffic; without spending a dime on light rail extensions.

Instead three years later Sound Transit’s response was typified by their 2019 2nd quarter ST Express Revenue Vehicle Miles, 3,025,786; only 13% higher than the comparable 2,675,453 level in 2009.  Even worse Sound Transit intends to use light rail to replace existing bus routes rather than increasing bus service.  Rogoff’s 2019 budget projects no increase in bus ridership between 2017 and 2041. 

They also could have told readers CEO Rogoff’s 2019 budget projections for light rail ridership increasing over the 2017 to 2041 period were delusional.  A 2004 PSRC study, funded by Sound Transit, concluded the Downtown Seattle Transit Tunnel (DSTT) limited Central Link capacity to 8880 riders per hour in each direction.  The billions spent on light rail spine over the next two decades do nothing to increase that capacity.  Yet the Sound Transit budget projects light rail ridership will increase from 22 million annually in 2017 to 162 million in 2041.

Anyone with a modicum of transportation competence would recognize Sound Transit doesn’t recognize either the benefits of BRT or the limits of light rail in Seattle.  Unfortunately the Traffic Lab has spent another year refusing to do so.

Thursday, October 3, 2019

Why I’m A Stop East Link Now Candidate


My candidacy this year, like my previous 7 candidacies, is not about winning but attracting attention to Sound Transit and WSDOT failed transportation policies and the Seattle Times failure to acknowledge that failure.  (I recognized there was very little any individual city or county council member or legislator could do to change their policies)

My candidacy allowed me to use my candidate’s statement in the Voters’ Pamphlet to attract attention to this blog exposing those problems and also do so at candidate forums. My post has now attracted more than 135,000 views.  However it’s October and so far I have yet to be asked to participate in any forums so this post is intended to go beyond the 200-word limit in Voters’ Pamphlet detailing my concerns.

This year marks more than a decade of attempts to expose Sound Transit East Link mendacity and incompetence.  It began in early 2009 when I told the Bellevue city council a 2004 PSRC study, funded by Sound Transit, concluded the Downtown Seattle Transit Tunnel (DSTT) limited Central Link capacity to 8880 riders per hour in each direction.

That East Link’s share of that capacity debunked Sound Transit’s 2008 DEIS claim East Link would have peak hour capacity of up to 24,000 people per hour, the equivalent of up to 10 lanes of freeway”.  

I urged the Bellevue City Council either require Sound Transit consider or fund their own study comparing light rail with BRT before approving the 10 permits Sound Transit needed for East Link. Even a cursory analysis would have concluded Sound Transit could have added 4th lanes to the I-90 Bridge outer roadways and implemented two-way BRT on center roadway with 10 times light rail capacity at a fraction of light rail cost. 

Instead the Bellevue council approved the permits Sound Transit needed, resulting in their confiscating the i-90 Bridge center roadway and devastating the route into Bellevue for an East Link light rail system that will never have the transit capacity needed to reduce cross lake congestion and precluding BRT that could.

The council also abided Sound Transit delaying the 4th lanes to I-90 bridge outer roadways despite the obvious benefit for commuters from both sides of the lake.  Sound Transit “likely” recognized the added 4th lanes would allow two-way bus routes on center roadway that would have ended any support for light rail.  

Those concerns prompted them to delay adding lanes until they closed the bridge center roadway precluding any central roadway BRT assessment.  Cross-lake commuters endured years of increased congestion because of the delay.

I also urged the council consider a 2004 FHA Record of Decision conclusion the center roadway was still needed for vehicles with the added outer roadway lanes.  That conclusion refuted Sound Transit DEIS claims "Travel times across I-90 for vehicles would also improve or remain similar with East Link". 

It also refuted Sound Transit/WSDOT claim to a federal judge in the Freeman litigation light rail could be installed on center roadway since it wasn’t needed for vehicles.  The fact that it currently takes an average of 42 minutes for the 15.5-mile commute from Issaquah to Seattle confirms the FHA assessment.

The real absurdity is East Link operation, rather than reducing that commute time, will undoubtedly increase it.  The problem being Sound Transit intends to use East Link to replace all I-90 buses.  First of all, using East Link to replace current I-90 buses would have minimal affect on HOV lanes and none on GP lanes. 

Even worse, Sound Transit and King County Metro both agreed to halve current I-90 corridor buses as part of their “bus intercept” agreement with Mercer Island.  Thus East Link operation will result in hundreds if not thousands of current transit riders forced to drive, adding to congestion along the entire I-90 corridor.

It's "unfortunate" the Bellevue city council has enabled Sound Transit to spend $3.6 billion constructing a light rail extension that precludes BRT on I-90 Bridge center roadway and devastates the route into Bellevue.  Unfortunately very little can be done about that debacle.  However, it's "absurd" the Sound Transit/Mercer Island bus intercept agreement allows them to exacerbate the congestion.  Exposing that problem is just one of the reasons I run.

Sunday, September 29, 2019

Sound Transit Car Tab Mendacity


(I emailed this post to the Bellevue Reporter)

Sound Transit’s response to Initiative 976 in the Sept.7 Bellevue Reporter article, “Car tabs return to ballot in November” typifies their mendacity regarding the issue.  Prior to the 2016 vote a Sound Transit 7/8/2016 post entitled: “ST3 plan would cost typical adult $169 annually or $14 per month” included the following:

Here’s how much a typical adult would pay if ST3 is approved:
MVET
An adult owning the median value motor vehicle would pay an additional $43 per year in MVET if ST3 were passed. The updated calculation reflects an annual median value $5,333 of vehicles in the Sound Transit District.

The article claims Sound Transit would lose $20 Billion in revenue if the initiative passes.  Yet Sound Transit’s 2019 budget shows anticipated total MVET revenue between 2017 and 2041 was approximately $8 billion, and that was out of a total of $64 billion in tax revenue.  Thus it’s “unlikely” the loss in car tab tax revenue would delay projects for 20 years.


Sunday, September 22, 2019

What I-405 Corridor Advisory Group Should Do


The September 20th Bellevue Reporter article “Corridor advisory group discusses legislative session, projects at meeting” exemplifies their current flawed approach to I-405 congestion, what even the WSDOT acknowledges is “one of the state’s worst commutes”. 

The article suggests the Corridor advisory group doesn’t recognize the “problem” so it’s “unlikely” any suggestions they make will do much to reduce it.  First the lack of adequate public transit capacity.  The advisory group talks about how they propose “moving BRT stations” to shorten the current 57-minute ST express bus commutes between Lynnwood and Bellevue. 



However they ignore the fact that Sound Transit I-405 service from Lynnwood is limited to 6 ST535 buses between 6:30 and 9:30 am.  That Everett to Bellevue service is limited to 7 ST532 buses.  Clearly reducing travel times for those buses is “unlikely” to reduce I-405 congestion between Lynnwood and Bellevue.


Meanwhile, south of Bellevue, the 11-mile, Renton-to-Bellevue travel times are 60 minutes on GP lanes and 33 minutes on HOV lane.   Those travel times were the major reason the 23-mile Federal Way-to-Bellevue commute take 83 minutes on GP lanes and 51 minutes on HOV.  

Yet there are no I-405 bus routes between Federal Way and Bellevue and there are only 6 ST560 buses from Burien between 6:30 and 9:30 am. They take 58 minutes to reach Bellevue T/C because of stops at SeaTac and Renton T/C.

The corridor advisory group should “advise” Sound Transit dramatically increase I-405 bus service now rather than wait until 2024 to implement I-405 BRT.  That BRT works best with direct routes between a single P&R and destination, not a route with 10 stops between Lynnwood and Burien. 

During peak commute, I-405 BRT should provide each P&R with a non-stop bus route to Bellevue every 10 or 15 minutes, not a single bus every 10 minutes for the 10 stops along the entire route.  The corridor group should also “advise” Sound Transit to divert the $300 million they’re planning to spend on an 85th Ave T/C with no P&R for access towards added I-405 bus service and local routes to P&R lots. 

Second, the advisory group should recognize the WSDOT plans for 2 HOT lanes between Lynnwood and Renton will, at least during peak commute, increase BRT travel times. The HOT lanes are a major reason for the current 57-minute bus commutes between Lynnwood and Bellevue. The problem being the 2nd HOT lane eliminates a GP lane, increasing congestion to where more that 2000 drivers per hour are willing to pay the HOT fees than the HOV lane can accommodate and still attain 45 mph.  

They should “advise” WSDOT to limit HOT to one lane along the entire route with fees raised to limit traffic to the 2000 vehicles per hour.  Doing so would ensure 45 mph for those willing to pay and those riding buses. The added GP lane would reduce congestion for those unwilling or unable to pay. 

That’s what “advisory groups” are supposed to do.  Abiding Sound Transit and WSDOT current I-405 plans will exacerbate the congestion problem.

Wednesday, September 18, 2019

Ballard and West Seattle Deserve Tunnel


The Sept 13th, Seattle Times, B1 Page article “How light rail plans are shaping up in Seattle” typifies the Traffic Lab’s flawed approach to the area’s transportation problems. The article includes the following:

Tunnels in West Seattle and Ballard, along with other options for the international District/Chinatown and Interbay Stations could add $2 billion to what’s already an $8 billion-plus project without changing the expected daily ridership of 52,000 between Ballard and South Lake Union, and 35,000 between West Seattle and Stadium Station.  The downtown portion will serve more than 100,000 riders.

The Traffic Lab questions whether $2 billion more should be spent for tunnels to West Seattle and Ballard that won’t increase ridership.  Yet they ignored Sound Transit choosing to spend more than $2 billion on a Northgate extension tunnel with no expectation doing so would boost ridership. 

Even more absurd they have no problem with Sound Transit CEO Rogoff’s 2019 budget plan to spend most of $96 billion on a light rail spine along I-5 between Tacoma and Everett, and across I-90 through Bellevue to Redmond.  They do nothing to increase capacity of light rail routed through the Downtown Seattle Transit Tunnel (DSTT).  

Apparently the Traffic Lab doesn’t recognize a 2004 PSRC study, funded by Sound Transit, limited the DSTT capacity to 8880 riders per hour in each direction.  Not only are Sound Transit CEO Rogoff’s claims for the Prop 1 extensions delusional, any riders added will reduce access to this limited capacity for current riders. 

Sound Transit is already proceeding with plans to  spend $2.8 billion on an 8.5-mile Lynnwood Link that will double the operating costs of the Northgate Link but does nothing to increase capacity.  The entire area will be forced to spend countless millions each year to cover the shortfall between costs and fare-box revenue with the longer routes. 

Clearly spending an additional $2 billion to tunnel from Ballard all the way to West Seattle for 100,000 transit riders into Seattle would seem to be a relative bargain.  Especially with the low operating costs for the added riders with the relatively short extensions. There would be no ST3 funding without Seattle’s 70% approval.  If Sound Transit can tunnel to Northgate they can surely tunnel to Ballard and West Seattle. 



The bottom line is the Traffic Lab  still doesn’t recognize the billions spent on Prop 1 extensions will do nothing to increase light rail capacity into Seattle.  The Ballard and West Seattle  extensions will.  The real concerns should not be about the added $2 billion for tunnels, but the fact Sound Transit intends to delay them until 2030 and 2035.  They should be expedited, not delayed.